Review summary
Historical dates
June 13, 1752 – January 6, 1840Synthetic DOB
1752-06-13Index visit
1811-08-10 at age 59Synthetic MRN
HR-EN013-SYN-TDTeaching objective: Evaluate a palpable breast mass in a postmenopausal woman of 59 with diagnostic mammography, ultrasound, and core biopsy; complete receptor testing, extent-of-disease MRI, and germline testing; coordinate mastectomy with sentinel node biopsy under modern general and regional anesthesia; recognize and manage a postoperative seroma; and begin an aromatase inhibitor with the bone-health, lipid, lymphedema, and distress monitoring of the CMID breast cancer protocol.
Historical timeline
| Date | Event | Claims |
|---|---|---|
| June 13, 1752 | Born in King's Lynn, Norfolk. | CLM-0001 |
| 1762 | Her mother died. | CLM-0002 |
| January 1778 | Evelina published anonymously. | CLM-0004 |
| December 1794 | Birth of her only child. | CLM-0003 |
| About August 1810 | Began to feel a small pain in her breast. | CLM-0005 |
| September 30, 1811 | Mastectomy without anesthesia at her home in Paris. | CLM-0006, CLM-0008 |
| March to June 1812 | Wrote her account of the operation to her sister. | CLM-0007 |
| January 6, 1840 | Died, more than 28 years after the operation. | CLM-0009, CLM-0008 |
Evidence claims
D = documented, R = retrospective, S = synthetic.
| Grade | Claim | Certainty | Sources |
|---|---|---|---|
| D | Frances Burney was born in King's Lynn, Norfolk, on June 13, 1752. | confirmed | Frances Burney (1752-1840) supports |
| D | Burney's mother died in 1762, when Burney was about ten. No cause of death is given in the cited source. |
confirmed | Frances Burney (1752-1840) supports |
| D | Burney married Alexandre d'Arblay, whom she met in 1793, and her only child, Alexander, was born in December 1794, when she was 42. In April 1802 she and her son joined her husband in France, where they lived for about ten years. | confirmed | Frances Burney (1752-1840) supports Burney F. Journal letter to Esther Burney, March 22 to June 1812 ('A Mastectomy'), transcription for a university course supports |
| D | Burney was a novelist, diarist, and playwright. Her first novel, Evelina, was published anonymously in January 1778, and she published four novels between 1778 and 1814. | confirmed | Frances Burney (1752-1840) supports |
| D | In her letter Burney wrote that about August 1810 she began to be troubled by "a small pain in my breast," heavy rather than acute, which increased week by week. She resisted examination for some months; physicians and surgeons then treated her for months without success, the hardness of the affected spot increased, and her right arm was kept from use for many months. She noted that the breast was not discolored and not much larger than the other. Patient's own account of the onset and course. The contemporary label is the evidence; no modern diagnosis is inferred from it. |
confirmed | Burney F. Journal letter to Esther Burney, March 22 to June 1812 ('A Mastectomy'), transcription for a university course supports |
| D | On the last day of September 1811, at her home in Paris, Burney underwent removal of the breast without anesthesia. The operation was performed by the surgeon Larrey, surgeon of the Imperial Guard, with other physicians and surgeons present. She was given a wine cordial beforehand, and she wrote that the operation, including the dressing, lasted 20 minutes and that she believed she fainted twice. The documented operation that anchors the synthetic mastectomy. No statement by the surgeon or by her relatives is used. |
confirmed | Burney F. Journal letter to Esther Burney, March 22 to June 1812 ('A Mastectomy'), transcription for a university course supports Brandt L, Artmeier-Brandt U. Victory over surgical pain [in German]. Anaesthesist 2016;65(10):727-745. PMID 27421850 supports Lush R. I Thought I Must Have Expired - Experiences of Surgery Before Anaesthesia. J Anesth Hist 2020;6(2):35-37. PMID 32593374 context |
| D | Burney described the operation in a journal letter to her sister Esther, begun in March 1812 and finished in June 1812, nine months after the operation; she wrote that she dared not revise or read it, "the recollection is still so painful." The manuscript is in the Berg Collection of the New York Public Library. The letter is the primary source for the illness and the operation. |
confirmed | Burney F. Journal letter to Esther Burney, March 22 to June 1812 ('A Mastectomy'), transcription for a university course supports Meek H. Frances Burney's Mastectomy Narrative and Discourses of Breast Cancer in the Long Eighteenth Century. Lit Med 2017;35(1):27-45. PMID 28529229 supports |
| R | Whether Burney's breast disease was cancer is debated. Her letter and a modern biographical source call it breast cancer, but no tissue was examined; a 2024 article argues that it was tuberculosis rather than carcinoma. She lived for more than 28 years after the operation. Retrospective interpretation without pathology. The specific diagnosis is graded R and is not asserted as fact. |
disputed | Frances Burney (1752-1840) supports Burney F. Journal letter to Esther Burney, March 22 to June 1812 ('A Mastectomy'), transcription for a university course context Lippi D. Fanny Burney's mastectomy: tuberculosis not carcinoma. Vesalius 2024;1:11-28 disputes |
| D | Burney died on January 6, 1840, at 87. Record the death as a fact without detail. |
confirmed | Frances Burney (1752-1840) supports |
Modern synthetic problem list
| Grade | Problem | Clinical status | Verification | Placement | Historical claims |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| S | Invasive ductal carcinoma of the right breast, upper outer quadrant at 10 o'clock, presenting as a firm lump after about a year of breast ache; core biopsy: grade 2, estrogen and progesterone receptor positive, HER2 negative; clinical stage T2 N0 (cT2 cN0 M0); synthetic modern diagnosis linked to the documented 1811 breast disease and mastectomy, whose cancer diagnosis is debated | active | confirmed | both_with_link | CLM-0005, CLM-0006, CLM-0008 |
| S | Estrogen receptor positive status of the breast cancer (ER 95 percent, PR 70 percent) | active | confirmed | active | CLM-0008 |
| S | Absence of the right breast after total mastectomy without reconstruction, her choice | active | confirmed | active | CLM-0006 |
| S | Long-term use of anastrozole as adjuvant endocrine therapy | active | confirmed | active | |
| S | Low bone mass (osteopenia) on baseline DXA before anastrozole: lumbar spine T-score -1.4, femoral neck -1.7; 10-year major osteoporotic fracture risk about 8 percent (FRAX); vitamin D insufficiency | active | confirmed | active | |
| S | Seroma under the right mastectomy flap after drain removal, without infection; aspirated once by the breast surgery team; resolved | resolved | confirmed | active | |
| S | Firm lump in the upper outer quadrant of the right breast after about a year of heavy breast ache; clinically suspicious, imaging and biopsy booked | resolved | confirmed | active | CLM-0005 |
Synthetic outcome measures
| Grade | Date | Measure | Result | Coding |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| S | 1811-08-10 | Patient Health Questionnaire 2 item (PHQ-2) total score [Reported] | 1 | http://loinc.org · 55758-7 |
| S | 1811-08-24 | Patient Health Questionnaire 9 item (PHQ-9) total score [Reported] | 5 | http://loinc.org · 44261-6 |
| S | 1811-08-24 | Generalized anxiety disorder 7 item (GAD-7) total score [Reported.PHQ] | 7 | http://loinc.org · 70274-6 |
| S | 1811-10-19 | Cholesterol [Mass/volume] in Serum or Plasma | 214 mg/dL (high) Reference <=199 mg/dL |
http://loinc.org · 2093-3 |
| S | 1811-10-19 | Cholesterol in HDL [Mass/volume] in Serum or Plasma | 58 mg/dL Reference >=50 mg/dL |
http://loinc.org · 2085-9 |
| S | 1811-10-19 | Cholesterol in LDL [Mass/volume] in Serum or Plasma by calculation | 132 mg/dL (high) Reference <=99 mg/dL |
http://loinc.org · 13457-7 |
| S | 1811-10-19 | Triglyceride [Mass/volume] in Serum or Plasma | 120 mg/dL Reference <=149 mg/dL |
http://loinc.org · 2571-8 |
| S | 1811-10-19 | 25-Hydroxyvitamin D3+25-Hydroxyvitamin D2 [Mass/volume] in Serum or Plasma | 24 ng/mL (low) Reference 30-100 ng/mL |
http://loinc.org · 62292-8 |
| S | 1811-10-19 | Patient Health Questionnaire 2 item (PHQ-2) total score [Reported] | 1 | http://loinc.org · 55758-7 |
| S | 1811-10-19 | DXA Lumbar spine [T-score] Bone density | -1.4 (low) Reference >=-1 |
http://loinc.org · 38267-1 |
| S | 1811-10-19 | DXA Femur [T-score] Bone density | -1.7 (low) Reference >=-1 |
http://loinc.org · 38263-0 |
| S | 1811-10-29 | Patient Health Questionnaire 2 item (PHQ-2) total score [Reported] | 0 | http://loinc.org · 55758-7 |
| S | 1811-10-29 | Total score [AUDIT-C] | 2 | http://loinc.org · 75626-2 |
Synthetic vital signs
| Date | Measure | Result | LOINC | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1811-08-10 | Body height | 160 cm | 8302-2 | S |
| 1811-08-10 | Body weight | 62 kg | 29463-7 | S |
| 1811-08-10 | Body mass index (BMI) [Ratio] | 24.2 kg/m2 | 39156-5 | S |
| 1811-08-10 | Systolic blood pressure | 128 mm[Hg] | 8480-6 | S |
| 1811-08-10 | Diastolic blood pressure | 80 mm[Hg] | 8462-4 | S |
| 1811-08-10 | Heart rate | 82 /min | 8867-4 | S |
| 1811-08-10 | Respiratory rate | 14 /min | 9279-1 | S |
| 1811-08-10 | Body temperature | 36.7 Cel | 8310-5 | S |
| 1811-08-10 | Oxygen saturation in Arterial blood by Pulse oximetry | 99 % | 59408-5 | S |
| 1811-08-24 | Body height | 160 cm | 8302-2 | S |
| 1811-08-24 | Body weight | 61.6 kg | 29463-7 | S |
| 1811-08-24 | Body mass index (BMI) [Ratio] | 24.1 kg/m2 | 39156-5 | S |
| 1811-08-24 | Systolic blood pressure | 132 mm[Hg] | 8480-6 | S |
| 1811-08-24 | Diastolic blood pressure | 82 mm[Hg] | 8462-4 | S |
| 1811-08-24 | Heart rate | 86 /min | 8867-4 | S |
| 1811-08-24 | Respiratory rate | 14 /min | 9279-1 | S |
| 1811-08-24 | Body temperature | 36.6 Cel | 8310-5 | S |
| 1811-08-24 | Oxygen saturation in Arterial blood by Pulse oximetry | 99 % | 59408-5 | S |
| 1811-10-19 | Body height | 160 cm | 8302-2 | S |
| 1811-10-19 | Body weight | 60.9 kg | 29463-7 | S |
| 1811-10-19 | Body mass index (BMI) [Ratio] | 23.8 kg/m2 | 39156-5 | S |
| 1811-10-19 | Systolic blood pressure | 122 mm[Hg] | 8480-6 | S |
| 1811-10-19 | Diastolic blood pressure | 76 mm[Hg] | 8462-4 | S |
| 1811-10-19 | Heart rate | 74 /min | 8867-4 | S |
| 1811-10-19 | Respiratory rate | 14 /min | 9279-1 | S |
| 1811-10-19 | Body temperature | 36.6 Cel | 8310-5 | S |
| 1811-10-19 | Oxygen saturation in Arterial blood by Pulse oximetry | 99 % | 59408-5 | S |
| 1811-10-08 | Body height | 160 cm | 8302-2 | S |
| 1811-10-08 | Body weight | 60.8 kg | 29463-7 | S |
| 1811-10-08 | Body mass index (BMI) [Ratio] | 23.7 kg/m2 | 39156-5 | S |
| 1811-10-08 | Systolic blood pressure | 124 mm[Hg] | 8480-6 | S |
| 1811-10-08 | Diastolic blood pressure | 78 mm[Hg] | 8462-4 | S |
| 1811-10-08 | Heart rate | 80 /min | 8867-4 | S |
| 1811-10-08 | Respiratory rate | 14 /min | 9279-1 | S |
| 1811-10-08 | Body temperature | 36.9 Cel | 8310-5 | S |
| 1811-10-08 | Oxygen saturation in Arterial blood by Pulse oximetry | 99 % | 59408-5 | S |
| 1811-10-29 | Body height | 160 cm | 8302-2 | S |
| 1811-10-29 | Body weight | 61.2 kg | 29463-7 | S |
| 1811-10-29 | Body mass index (BMI) [Ratio] | 23.9 kg/m2 | 39156-5 | S |
| 1811-10-29 | Systolic blood pressure | 120 mm[Hg] | 8480-6 | S |
| 1811-10-29 | Diastolic blood pressure | 76 mm[Hg] | 8462-4 | S |
| 1811-10-29 | Heart rate | 72 /min | 8867-4 | S |
| 1811-10-29 | Respiratory rate | 14 /min | 9279-1 | S |
| 1811-10-29 | Body temperature | 36.6 Cel | 8310-5 | S |
| 1811-10-29 | Oxygen saturation in Arterial blood by Pulse oximetry | 99 % | 59408-5 | S |
Social, functional, and mental status
Social history
- S Occupation: novelist and diarist; writes most mornings and keeps a journal and long letters to her family
- S Never smoker; a glass of wine with dinner two or three times a week; walks daily
- S Lives with her husband in a first-floor apartment; their adult son lives nearby; independent
- S Supports: her husband and son and a wide circle of friends who visit often
- S Reproductive history: one pregnancy, first and only birth at 42; menopause at 51; never used menopausal hormone therapy
Functional status
- S Independent in all activities of daily living before surgery; walks 30 minutes a day
- S Three weeks after surgery: independent; right shoulder flexion 150 degrees and improving with exercises
Mental status
- S Alert, articulate, and observant; anxious about an operation and asks to be told plainly, and in advance, what will be done and when
- S Mood steady; PHQ-9 5 and GAD-7 7 at diagnosis, mild
Allergies and medications
Allergies
- S No known allergy
Medications
- S Acetaminophen 500 mg oral tablet, two tablets (1000 mg) by mouth every 6 hours for pain after surgery, no more than 3000 mg a day
- S Ibuprofen 400 mg oral tablet, one tablet by mouth every 8 hours with food for five days after surgery
- S Anastrozole 1 mg oral tablet, one tablet by mouth once daily, planned for five years
- S Cholecalciferol (vitamin D3) 1000 units oral tablet, one tablet by mouth once daily
Procedures and immunizations
Procedures
- S Diagnostic bilateral mammography: 2.4 cm irregular spiculated mass at 10 o'clock in the upper outer right breast; heterogeneously dense breasts; left breast normal; BI-RADS 5
- S Right breast and axillary ultrasound: 2.5 cm irregular hypoechoic mass at 10 o'clock, 6 cm from the nipple; normal axillary lymph nodes
- S Ultrasound-guided core needle biopsy of the right breast mass with clip placement: invasive ductal carcinoma, grade 2; ER 95 percent, PR 70 percent, HER2 1+ (negative), Ki-67 15 percent
- S Bilateral breast MRI with contrast for extent of disease: index mass 2.6 cm; a second 0.8 cm enhancing mass at 7 o'clock in the right breast, 5 cm from the index mass; left breast normal; no enlarged nodes
- S MRI-guided core needle biopsy of the second right breast lesion: invasive ductal carcinoma, grade 2, ER positive, HER2 negative (multicentric disease)
- S Right total mastectomy without reconstruction, her choice, under general anesthesia; overnight stay. Pathology: multicentric invasive ductal carcinoma, 2.6 cm and 0.8 cm, grade 2, margins clear, no lymphovascular invasion; pT2(m) pN0(sn), anatomic stage IIA. Recurrence score (21-gene assay) 13
- S Right axillary sentinel lymph node biopsy at mastectomy (radioisotope and blue dye): 0 of 3 nodes involved
- S Ultrasound-guided pectoral nerve block (PECS II) with ropivacaine before incision, for pain control after mastectomy
- S Baseline bone density scan (DXA) before anastrozole: lumbar spine T-score -1.4, femoral neck T-score -1.7 (low bone mass)
- S Aspiration of a right chest wall seroma by the breast surgery team: 140 mL of clear straw-colored fluid; no signs of infection
Immunizations
- S 1810-10-20: Influenza vaccine, 1810-1811 season
- S 1805-04-15: Tdap vaccine
- S 1811-10-29: Influenza vaccine, 1811-1812 season
- S 1811-10-29: Pneumococcal conjugate vaccine PCV20
- S 1811-10-29: Recombinant zoster vaccine, dose 1 of 2
Past medical history
True biography with historical dates; not part of the synthetic care timeline.
- D December 1794: One pregnancy; her only child born when she was 42 (CLM-0003)
- D About August 1810: A small, heavy pain in the breast from about August 1810, increasing week by week, treated for months without success, with a hardening of the affected spot and her right arm kept from use; the breast was not discolored (CLM-0005)
Family history
- D mother: Died in 1762, when Burney was about ten; cause not recorded in the cited source
Care-plan goals
| Goal | Target date | Status | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| Complete diagnosis, staging, and surgery within eight weeks of presentation | 1811-10-19 | completed | Core biopsy in four days, MRI and a second biopsy within four weeks, mastectomy at seven weeks |
| Surgery under anesthesia with pain controlled without opioids after discharge | 1811-10-19 | completed | Pain 2 out of 10 by the third day; no opioid after leaving hospital; acetaminophen stopped at two weeks |
| Start adjuvant endocrine therapy with a bone-health plan | 1811-10-19 | completed | Anastrozole started; baseline DXA shows low bone mass; vitamin D started |
| Regain full right shoulder movement and keep lymphedema risk low | 1811-10-29 | active | Shoulder flexion 165 degrees at four weeks, nearly full, with physical therapy under way; arm circumferences equal |
Interventions
| Intervention | Status | Guideline |
|---|---|---|
| Diagnostic mammography and ultrasound, then image-guided core biopsy with ER, PR, and HER2 testing, for a palpable breast mass in a woman of 59 | completed | GL-NCCN-BREAST-2025, GL-CMID-2026 |
| Breast surgery consultation to discuss surgical options, imaging of the extent of disease, axillary staging, and anesthesia and pain control | completed | GL-NCCN-BREAST-2025 |
| Germline genetic testing before surgery, as recommended for breast cancer diagnosed at 65 or younger | completed | GL-ASCO-SSO-GERM-2024 |
| Right total mastectomy with sentinel lymph node biopsy under general anesthesia with a pectoral nerve block and an opioid-sparing recovery pathway | completed | GL-NCCN-BREAST-2025 |
| Anastrozole 1 mg daily for five years, with a baseline DXA repeated every two years, vitamin D and calcium, lipid monitoring, and questions about joint pain, hot flashes, and vaginal symptoms at every visit | completed | GL-ASCO-ENDO-2019, GL-CMID-2026 |
| Survivorship care: history and examination every 3 to 6 months for 3 years and a yearly mammogram of the left breast, with no routine blood tests or body imaging; lymphedema counseling and shoulder exercises; distress screening; a written survivorship care plan | completed | GL-CMID-2026, GL-ACS-ASCO-SURV-2016, GL-ASCO-FU-2013 |
Planned encounters
- 1811-08-10 — Primary care visit for a right breast lump and a year of breast ache (ENC-001)
- 1811-08-24 — Review of mammogram, ultrasound, and core biopsy showing breast cancer; breast surgery consultation (ENC-002)
- 1811-10-08 — Same-day sick visit for swelling under the mastectomy scar (ENC-004, unscheduled)
- 1811-10-19 — Review three weeks after right mastectomy; start of endocrine therapy and survivorship care (ENC-003)
- 1811-10-29 — Adult preventive visit (ENC-005)
Supporting documents
- History and physical
- Progress note 01
- Progress note 02 — Focused Visit (Intermediate follow-up)
- Progress note 03 — Sick Visit
- Progress note 04 — Focused Visit (Care-plan review)
- Progress note 05 — Preventive Visit
- Breast Surgery referral
- Breast Surgery consultation
- Patient care plan
- Teaching note
- Provenance CSV
C-CDA note documents
Each link opens a readable copy; the XML beside it is the exchange file.
- History and physical (XML)
- Progress note 01 (XML)
- Progress note 02 — Focused Visit (Intermediate follow-up) (XML)
- Progress note 03 — Sick Visit (XML)
- Progress note 04 — Focused Visit (Care-plan review) (XML)
- Progress note 05 — Preventive Visit (XML)
- Breast Surgery referral (XML)
- Breast Surgery consultation (XML)
Sources
Review status
| Review | Status | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| schema validation | not_started | Run scripts/build.ps1 -Conformance. |
| clinical review | not_started | Awaiting clinician review; check the choice of MRI, mastectomy for multicentric disease, the omission of radiation and chemotherapy, and the bone-health plan on anastrozole. |
| provenance review | not_started | Burney's own letter (a public-domain transcription), the Grub Street Project entry, and three article abstracts logged; whether the disease was cancer is graded R and disputed; no statement by the surgeon or her relatives is used. |
| safe messaging review | not_started | No behavioral-health diagnosis; the operation is recorded from her own account without graphic detail; her dread of surgery is respected in the synthetic plan. |
Comments and corrections
Sign in with GitHub to comment on this record. To report a specific error, ideally with a source, use the feedback form; each report becomes a tracked issue.
Comments appear on the online version of this page.