Review summary
Teaching objective: Primary care for a 25-year-old private pilot with chronic sinus symptoms: diagnosis of chronic rhinosinusitis by symptoms plus objective evidence (nasal endoscopy), the SNOT-22 symptom score, a check for conditions that change management, high-volume saline irrigation and an intranasal steroid as first-line treatment, a culture-directed antibiotic only for an acute exacerbation with pus and no oral steroid for disease without polyps, CT of the sinuses only after appropriate medical therapy, the appropriateness criteria for endoscopic sinus surgery and a shared decision about it, and aviation medicine: sinus and ear barotrauma, not flying while symptomatic, a 48-hour ground trial of new medicines, which medicines the FAA accepts for pilots, and return to flying after surgery, on the AAO-HNS adult sinusitis guideline (1912 update), the ICAR rhinosinusitis consensus (1918), the RAND/UCLA appropriateness criteria for sinus surgery, and the FAA Guide for Aviation Medical Examiners.
Historical timeline
| Date | Event | Claims |
|---|---|---|
| July 24, 1897 | Born in Atchison, Kansas. | CLM-0001 |
| February 1918 | Moved to Toronto; Voluntary Aid Detachment work at the Spadina Military Hospital. | CLM-0002 |
| 1918 | Severe sinus illness during the influenza epidemic, treated with sinus drainage. | CLM-0003 |
| December 1920 | First airplane ride. | CLM-0005 |
| 1924 | Sinus operation for chronic sinus headaches, before returning to Columbia for the winter of 1924 to 1925. | CLM-0006 |
| 1928 | Transatlantic flight in the Friendship, as a passenger. | CLM-0008 |
| February 1931 | Married George Palmer Putnam. | CLM-0009 |
| May 1932 | First woman to fly solo across the Atlantic. | CLM-0008 |
| July 2, 1937 | Disappeared over the Pacific; radio contact lost. | CLM-0010 |
| 1939 | Declared legally dead by the Superior Court in Los Angeles. | CLM-0010 |
Evidence claims
D = documented, R = retrospective, S = synthetic.
| Grade | Claim | Certainty | Sources |
|---|---|---|---|
| D | Amelia Mary Earhart was born on July 24, 1897, in Atchison, Kansas, to Amy Otis and Edwin Stanton Earhart. | confirmed | Amelia Earhart Biographical Sketch supports Earhart, Amelia (1897-1937) supports |
| D | After visiting her sister in Toronto at Christmas 1917, she moved there in February 1918 and worked in the Voluntary Aid Detachment at the Spadina Military Hospital, often on twelve-hour shifts, going wherever an extra pair of hands was needed. Her wartime hospital work anchors the modern social history (an interest in medicine). |
confirmed | Amelia Earhart Biographical Sketch supports Gilmar PJ. The Canadian heart of Amelia Earhart supports March W. Amelia Earhart: Canadian aviation protege supports |
| D | During the 1918 influenza epidemic she worked nights on the ward that held the influenza patients; within weeks she fell ill herself, with severe sinus pain and terrible headaches. Her case was serious enough that doctors operated, opening into her sinuses so that they could be drained regularly. It was a month before she was well enough to leave hospital, and she went to recover at her sister's home in Massachusetts. The anchor for the modern episode. The account comes from a Toronto historian's article; no medical record was fetched, and which sinus was involved and how many drainage procedures she had are not stated in the fetched sources. |
probable | Bunch A. Amelia Earhart falls in love with flying supports |
| D | She suffered from chronic sinus problems for the rest of her life. The reason the modern episode centers on chronic rhinosinusitis. |
probable | Bunch A. Amelia Earhart falls in love with flying supports HISTMED Master Roster v3 context |
| D | She entered Columbia University as a pre-medical student in the fall of 1919 and left in 1920. She took her first airplane ride in December 1920, with the pilot Frank Hawks, and became a licensed pilot in the early 1920s: Purdue University dates her pilot's license to May 1923, and the Encyclopedia of the Great Plains to 1921. Her flying anchors the modern occupational history; the modern episode makes her a private pilot. |
confirmed | Amelia Earhart Biographical Sketch supports Earhart, Amelia (1897-1937) supports |
| D | After undergoing a sinus operation to relieve her chronic sinus headaches, she returned to Columbia University for the winter of 1924 to 1925. After the index date; recorded as history only. The modern episode's sinus surgery is synthetic and is not a claim about this operation. |
confirmed | Amelia Earhart Biographical Sketch supports |
| R | In modern terms, sinus disease that began with a severe sinus infection during influenza, needed drainage operations, and caused lasting headaches and sinus trouble fits chronic rhinosinusitis. The fetched sources give no diagnosis in those terms, and nothing is known of her sinus anatomy or of nasal polyps. A retrospective reading made for this record; the modern diagnosis is synthetic. |
possible | Bunch A. Amelia Earhart falls in love with flying context Amelia Earhart Biographical Sketch context HISTMED Master Roster v3 context |
| D | She accompanied the pilot Wilmer Stultz and the mechanic Louis Gordon on their 1928 transatlantic flight in the Friendship, but did not fly the plane herself. In May 1932 she became the first woman, and the second person, to fly solo across the Atlantic. After the index date; recorded as history only. |
confirmed | Amelia Earhart Biographical Sketch supports Earhart, Amelia (1897-1937) supports |
| D | In February 1931 she married the publisher George Palmer Putnam in Noank, Connecticut. After the index date; recorded as history only. No modern role is given to any real person. |
confirmed | Amelia Earhart Biographical Sketch supports |
| D | Radio contact with her aircraft was lost on July 2, 1937, during her attempt to fly around the world; she and her navigator, Fred Noonan, disappeared over the Pacific. She was declared legally dead in 1939 by the Superior Court in Los Angeles. History only, stated without speculation about her fate. |
confirmed | Amelia Earhart Biographical Sketch supports Earhart, Amelia (1897-1937) supports |
Modern synthetic problem list
| Grade | Problem | Clinical status | Verification | Placement | Historical claims |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| S | Nasal blockage, thick discolored nasal drainage, pressure over the left cheek and forehead, and a reduced sense of smell for about five months, with pressure pain in the left cheek on descent when flying. Anterior rhinoscopy shows swollen, red inferior turbinates without visible polyps or pus; SNOT-22 52. Suspected chronic rhinosinusitis; nasal endoscopy and otolaryngology consultation booked | resolved | confirmed | active | CLM-0003, CLM-0004, CLM-0007 |
| S | Chronic rhinosinusitis without nasal polyps: more than 12 weeks of nasal blockage, discolored drainage, facial pressure and reduced smell, confirmed by nasal endoscopy showing mucosal swelling and mucopurulent drainage from the left middle meatus, with no polyps on either side; an acute exacerbation at diagnosis. Synthetic modern episode linked to her documented chronic sinus trouble | active | confirmed | active | CLM-0003, CLM-0004, CLM-0007 |
| S | Left middle ear barotrauma after an airline flight taken during a cold: ear pain, fullness and muffled hearing from the descent, with a retracted left eardrum, a little bleeding within the drum, and fluid behind it; conductive hearing loss on tuning-fork tests; no vertigo or signs of inner-ear injury; resolved | resolved | confirmed | active |
Synthetic outcome measures
| Grade | Date | Measure | Result | Coding |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| S | 1923-06-08 | Eosinophils [#/volume] in Blood by Automated count | 0.21 10*3/uL Reference 0-0.5 10*3/uL |
http://loinc.org · 711-2 |
| S | 1923-06-08 | IgE [Units/volume] in Serum or Plasma | 42 [IU]/mL Reference <=100 [IU]/mL |
http://loinc.org · 19113-0 |
| S | 1923-06-08 | Pain severity - 0-10 verbal numeric rating [Score] - Reported | 6 | http://loinc.org · 72514-3 |
| S | 1923-06-08 | Patient Health Questionnaire 2 item (PHQ-2) total score [Reported] | 1 | http://loinc.org · 55758-7 |
| S | 1923-06-22 | Pain severity - 0-10 verbal numeric rating [Score] - Reported | 7 | http://loinc.org · 72514-3 |
| S | 1923-08-17 | Pain severity - 0-10 verbal numeric rating [Score] - Reported | 4 | http://loinc.org · 72514-3 |
| S | 1923-10-12 | Pain severity - 0-10 verbal numeric rating [Score] - Reported | 1 | http://loinc.org · 72514-3 |
| S | 1923-07-06 | Patient Health Questionnaire 2 item (PHQ-2) total score [Reported] | 0 | http://loinc.org · 55758-7 |
| S | 1923-07-06 | Total score [AUDIT-C] | 0 | http://loinc.org · 75626-2 |
Synthetic vital signs
| Date | Measure | Result | LOINC | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1923-06-08 | Body height | 173 cm | 8302-2 | S |
| 1923-06-08 | Body weight | 57 kg | 29463-7 | S |
| 1923-06-08 | Body mass index (BMI) [Ratio] | 19 kg/m2 | 39156-5 | S |
| 1923-06-08 | Systolic blood pressure | 112 mm[Hg] | 8480-6 | S |
| 1923-06-08 | Diastolic blood pressure | 70 mm[Hg] | 8462-4 | S |
| 1923-06-08 | Heart rate | 72 /min | 8867-4 | S |
| 1923-06-08 | Respiratory rate | 14 /min | 9279-1 | S |
| 1923-06-08 | Body temperature | 36.8 Cel | 8310-5 | S |
| 1923-06-08 | Oxygen saturation in Arterial blood by Pulse oximetry | 99 % | 59408-5 | S |
| 1923-06-22 | Body height | 173 cm | 8302-2 | S |
| 1923-06-22 | Body weight | 56.8 kg | 29463-7 | S |
| 1923-06-22 | Body mass index (BMI) [Ratio] | 19 kg/m2 | 39156-5 | S |
| 1923-06-22 | Systolic blood pressure | 114 mm[Hg] | 8480-6 | S |
| 1923-06-22 | Diastolic blood pressure | 72 mm[Hg] | 8462-4 | S |
| 1923-06-22 | Heart rate | 80 /min | 8867-4 | S |
| 1923-06-22 | Respiratory rate | 14 /min | 9279-1 | S |
| 1923-06-22 | Body temperature | 37.6 Cel | 8310-5 | S |
| 1923-06-22 | Oxygen saturation in Arterial blood by Pulse oximetry | 99 % | 59408-5 | S |
| 1923-08-17 | Body height | 173 cm | 8302-2 | S |
| 1923-08-17 | Body weight | 57.2 kg | 29463-7 | S |
| 1923-08-17 | Body mass index (BMI) [Ratio] | 19.1 kg/m2 | 39156-5 | S |
| 1923-08-17 | Systolic blood pressure | 110 mm[Hg] | 8480-6 | S |
| 1923-08-17 | Diastolic blood pressure | 70 mm[Hg] | 8462-4 | S |
| 1923-08-17 | Heart rate | 68 /min | 8867-4 | S |
| 1923-08-17 | Respiratory rate | 14 /min | 9279-1 | S |
| 1923-08-17 | Body temperature | 36.7 Cel | 8310-5 | S |
| 1923-08-17 | Oxygen saturation in Arterial blood by Pulse oximetry | 99 % | 59408-5 | S |
| 1923-10-12 | Body height | 173 cm | 8302-2 | S |
| 1923-10-12 | Body weight | 57.4 kg | 29463-7 | S |
| 1923-10-12 | Body mass index (BMI) [Ratio] | 19.2 kg/m2 | 39156-5 | S |
| 1923-10-12 | Systolic blood pressure | 112 mm[Hg] | 8480-6 | S |
| 1923-10-12 | Diastolic blood pressure | 68 mm[Hg] | 8462-4 | S |
| 1923-10-12 | Heart rate | 66 /min | 8867-4 | S |
| 1923-10-12 | Respiratory rate | 14 /min | 9279-1 | S |
| 1923-10-12 | Body temperature | 36.6 Cel | 8310-5 | S |
| 1923-10-12 | Oxygen saturation in Arterial blood by Pulse oximetry | 99 % | 59408-5 | S |
| 1923-07-06 | Body height | 173 cm | 8302-2 | S |
| 1923-07-06 | Body weight | 57 kg | 29463-7 | S |
| 1923-07-06 | Body mass index (BMI) [Ratio] | 19 kg/m2 | 39156-5 | S |
| 1923-07-06 | Systolic blood pressure | 110 mm[Hg] | 8480-6 | S |
| 1923-07-06 | Diastolic blood pressure | 70 mm[Hg] | 8462-4 | S |
| 1923-07-06 | Heart rate | 68 /min | 8867-4 | S |
| 1923-07-06 | Respiratory rate | 14 /min | 9279-1 | S |
| 1923-07-06 | Body temperature | 36.7 Cel | 8310-5 | S |
| 1923-07-06 | Oxygen saturation in Arterial blood by Pulse oximetry | 99 % | 59408-5 | S |
| 1923-07-20 | Body height | 173 cm | 8302-2 | S |
| 1923-07-20 | Body weight | 56.8 kg | 29463-7 | S |
| 1923-07-20 | Body mass index (BMI) [Ratio] | 19 kg/m2 | 39156-5 | S |
| 1923-07-20 | Systolic blood pressure | 112 mm[Hg] | 8480-6 | S |
| 1923-07-20 | Diastolic blood pressure | 70 mm[Hg] | 8462-4 | S |
| 1923-07-20 | Heart rate | 74 /min | 8867-4 | S |
| 1923-07-20 | Respiratory rate | 14 /min | 9279-1 | S |
| 1923-07-20 | Body temperature | 37.1 Cel | 8310-5 | S |
| 1923-07-20 | Oxygen saturation in Arterial blood by Pulse oximetry | 99 % | 59408-5 | S |
Social, functional, and mental status
Social history
- S Private pilot who flies a single-engine light aircraft most weekends from a local airfield and hopes to fly longer cross-country trips; holds a third-class FAA medical certificate. Worked as a hospital volunteer before learning to fly and is thinking of returning to pre-medical study
- S Works full time in an office on weekdays; lives alone in an apartment; single
- S Alcohol: does not drink; no cannabis or other drugs
- S Tobacco: never smoked; no vaping; avoids smoky rooms
- S Medicines tried: over-the-counter oxymetazoline spray for about two weeks last winter, stopped because the blockage came back worse; a nighttime cold tablet containing diphenhydramine on bad nights, which she did not know is a no-go medicine for pilots
- S Supports: her sister and a close friend from the airfield; flying instructors at the airfield. She decides who is told about her health
Functional status
- S Independent; sleep broken by blockage two or three nights a week; has cancelled four weekend flights in two months because of congestion or pressure pain
Mental status
- S Alert, cheerful and engaged; frustrated at missing flights; no low mood or loss of interest (PHQ-2 1)
Allergies and medications
Allergies
- S No known allergy
Medications
- S Sodium bicarbonate 700 mg and sodium chloride 2300 mg powder for nasal irrigation, one packet in 240 mL of distilled or boiled and cooled water, rinsing each side of the nose twice daily with a squeeze bottle
- S Fluticasone propionate 50 mcg per spray nasal spray, two sprays in each nostril once daily, aimed away from the septum
- S Acetaminophen 500 mg oral tablet, one or two tablets by mouth every 6 hours when needed for ear pain, no more than 6 tablets a day, for up to 5 days
- S Amoxicillin 875 mg and clavulanate 125 mg oral tablet, one tablet by mouth twice daily with food for 10 days
- S Budesonide 0.5 mg in 2 mL suspension (one ampule) added to a 240 mL saline rinse bottle, used as a high-volume rinse of both sides of the nose once daily, in place of the fluticasone spray
- S Acetaminophen 500 mg oral tablet, two tablets by mouth every 6 hours when needed for pain after sinus surgery, no more than 6 tablets a day
Procedures and immunizations
Procedures
- S Advance care planning conversation, about 16 minutes
- S Diagnostic nasal endoscopy with an endoscopically guided culture of the left middle meatus
- S CT of the paranasal sinuses without contrast, after ten weeks of medical therapy
- S Endoscopic sinus surgery on the left: maxillary antrostomy, anterior ethmoidectomy, and frontal recess dissection, as day surgery under general anesthesia
Immunizations
- S 1923-10-12: Influenza vaccine, 1923-1924 season
Past medical history
True biography with historical dates; not part of the synthetic care timeline.
- D 1918: Severe sinus infection with headaches during the 1918 influenza epidemic, while she worked nights on an influenza ward in Toronto, treated in hospital for about a month with operations that opened her sinuses for drainage (CLM-0003)
Family history
No family medical history is documented in the logged sources. Family history of real relatives is never synthesized.
Care-plan goals
| Goal | Target date | Status | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| SNOT-22 total score below 20 by four months | 1923-10-12 | completed | SNOT-22 12 five weeks after surgery |
| Fly without sinus or ear pressure pain, and only when she meets the FAA rule of not flying while symptomatic, by four months | 1923-10-12 | completed | Flying again since the ear, nose and throat clearance three weeks after surgery, without pressure pain |
| Use only medicines acceptable for pilots, with a 48-hour ground trial of each new medicine and no sedating antihistamine | 1923-10-12 | completed | No-go medicines stopped at intake; each new medicine started on a non-flying day |
| Saline irrigation and the nasal steroid used daily with correct technique | 1923-08-17 | completed | Daily use with correct technique at ten weeks; no nosebleeds |
Interventions
| Intervention | Status | Guideline |
|---|---|---|
| First-line medical therapy: high-volume saline irrigation twice daily and fluticasone nasal spray two sprays in each nostril daily, with technique taught in clinic; topical decongestant sprays stopped because rebound blockage follows use beyond a few days | completed | GL-AAOHNS-SINUS-2015, GL-ICAR-RS-2021 |
| Otolaryngology consultation with nasal endoscopy to confirm the diagnosis with objective evidence and to look for nasal polyps, and advice on further treatment, imaging, and surgery | completed | GL-AAOHNS-SINUS-2015, GL-ICAR-RS-2021 |
| Check for conditions that change management (asthma, cystic fibrosis, immune deficiency, ciliary dyskinesia, aspirin sensitivity, a dental source): history, blood eosinophils and total IgE; no imaging and no antifungal treatment at this stage | completed | GL-AAOHNS-SINUS-2015, GL-ICAR-RS-2021 |
| Fitness to fly: no flying while blocked or in pain, as 14 CFR 61.53 requires; a 48-hour ground trial before flying on any new medicine; only medicines the FAA accepts for pilots (nasal steroid sprays, saline, non-sedating antihistamines, pseudoephedrine); the diphenhydramine night tablet stopped, with at least 60 hours before flying after any dose; and practice of ear and sinus clearing on descent | completed | GL-FAA-OTC-2024, GL-FAA-ALLERGY-2026 |
| Culture-directed antibiotic for the acute exacerbation with pus in the middle meatus: an endoscopically guided culture and amoxicillin-clavulanate for 10 days; no oral corticosteroid, because her disease has no polyps; no long-term antibiotic | completed | GL-AAOHNS-SINUS-2015, GL-ICAR-RS-2021, GL-ABX-CRS-2022 |
| CT of the sinuses after at least eight weeks of irrigation and nasal steroid plus the antibiotic course, with the SNOT-22 repeated, to decide whether endoscopic sinus surgery is appropriate and to plan it | completed | GL-ICAR-RS-2021, GL-ESS-AC-2016 |
| Endoscopic sinus surgery on the left (maxillary antrostomy, anterior ethmoidectomy, and frontal recess dissection), chosen by her after a shared decision because the SNOT-22 stayed above 20 with disease on CT after appropriate medical therapy; then budesonide added to the saline rinse, cleaning of the sinuses in the ear, nose and throat clinic, and no flying until the surgeon clears her | completed | GL-ICAR-RS-2021, GL-ESS-AC-2016, GL-FAA-OTC-2024 |
Planned encounters
- 1923-06-08 — New patient, a private pilot, with five months of nasal blockage, discolored drainage, facial pressure and reduced smell: history, anterior rhinoscopy, symptom scoring, saline irrigation and an intranasal steroid, and fitness to fly (ENC-001)
- 1923-06-22 — Nasal endoscopy and otolaryngology consultation: diagnosis, an acute exacerbation, and the plan for imaging and surgery (ENC-002)
- 1923-07-06 — Periodic adult preventive visit (ENC-006)
- 1923-07-20 — Same-day sick visit for left ear pain after a flight (ENC-005, unscheduled)
- 1923-08-17 — Review after ten weeks of medical therapy: symptom score, sinus CT result, and the decision about surgery (ENC-003)
- 1923-10-12 — Review five weeks after endoscopic sinus surgery: symptoms, healing, pathology, and return to flying (ENC-004)
Supporting documents
- History and physical
- Progress note 01
- Progress note 02 — Focused Visit (Follow-up)
- Progress note 03 — Preventive Visit
- Progress note 04 — Sick Visit
- Progress note 05 — Focused Visit (Follow-up)
- Progress note 06 — Focused Visit (Care-plan review)
- Otolaryngology referral
- Otolaryngology consultation
- Patient care plan
- Teaching note
- Provenance CSV
C-CDA note documents
Each link opens a readable copy; the XML beside it is the exchange file.
- History and physical (XML)
- Progress note 01 (XML)
- Progress note 02 — Focused Visit (Follow-up) (XML)
- Progress note 03 — Preventive Visit (XML)
- Progress note 04 — Sick Visit (XML)
- Progress note 05 — Focused Visit (Follow-up) (XML)
- Progress note 06 — Focused Visit (Care-plan review) (XML)
- Otolaryngology referral (XML)
- Otolaryngology consultation (XML)
Sources
| ID | Source | Publisher | Type |
|---|---|---|---|
| SRC-0001 | Amelia Earhart Biographical Sketch | Purdue University Libraries, Archives and Special Collections (George Palmer Putnam Collection of Amelia Earhart Papers) | primary |
| SRC-0002 | Bunch A. Amelia Earhart falls in love with flying | The Toronto History Substack | other |
| SRC-0003 | Earhart, Amelia (1897-1937) | Encyclopedia of the Great Plains, University of Nebraska-Lincoln | biography |
| SRC-0004 | Gilmar PJ. The Canadian heart of Amelia Earhart | Legion Magazine | other |
| SRC-0005 | March W. Amelia Earhart: Canadian aviation protege | Department of National Defence, Royal Canadian Air Force (The Maple Leaf) | government |
| SRC-0006 | HISTMED Master Roster v3 | The Human Record project | other |
Review status
| Review | Status | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| schema validation | not_started | Run scripts/build.ps1 -Conformance. |
| clinical review | not_started | Awaiting clinician review; check the diagnosis of chronic rhinosinusitis without polyps by nasal endoscopy, the culture-directed antibiotic for an acute exacerbation and the decision against an oral steroid, CT only after appropriate medical therapy, the appropriateness criteria for sinus surgery, the left-sided surgery, and the FAA medication and return-to-flying advice. |
| provenance review | not_started | Purdue University Libraries' biographical sketch, the Encyclopedia of the Great Plains, Legion Magazine, the Department of National Defence (The Maple Leaf), and a Toronto historian's article logged. The 1918 illness and lasting sinus problems are D with certainty probable because they rest on one fetched popular-history source; the 1924 operation is from Purdue. Which sinus was involved, the number of operations, a drainage tube, and sinus trouble on specific flights could not be verified in a reliable fetched source and were left out. |
| safe messaging review | not_started | No mental-health or substance claims. Her disappearance is recorded as history only, without speculation about her fate. No modern role is given to any real person. |
Comments and corrections
Sign in with GitHub to comment on this record. To report a specific error, ideally with a source, use the feedback form; each report becomes a tracked issue.
Comments appear on the online version of this page.