Chronos Archive seal

Review checklist: Srinivasa Ramanujan (HR-ET020)

All records · Back to the record · Dossier (sources.md) · Terminology · Report a problem · Comments

Everything a reviewer needs to judge, gathered from the record. Release status: draft.

Review status

ReviewStatusReviewerDateNotes
schema validationnot_startedRun scripts/build.ps1 -Conformance.
clinical reviewnot_startedAwaiting clinician review; check the order of the tuberculosis and amebiasis evaluation, the decision not to aspirate, metronidazole then paromomycin, the diagnosis of latent infection only after negative cultures, rifampin after the liver tests normalized, oral B12 and vitamin D repletion, and the safety assessment.
provenance reviewnot_startedSources: MacTutor (St Andrews), the Oxford DNB entry reproduced by MacTutor, two Institute of Mathematical Sciences pages, the PubMed record of Young (1994), and Wikipedia for the naming note and context only. Kanigel's book and Young's full text were not read.
safe messaging reviewnot_startedThe reported suicide attempt (CLM-0014) is history only, graded R, marked sensitive, stated without method detail beyond the source's own words, and kept out of the modern episode, which ends before it would have occurred. The modern adjustment disorder and safety assessment are synthetic, record no suicidal ideation, and include the 988 Lifeline.

Judgment calls (dossier editorial resolutions)

  1. Recent-death rule. He died in 1920, so the rule does not apply. The record still treats the reported suicide attempt and his loneliness as sensitive.
  2. Name. In a Tamil name of this kind there is no family name: “Ramanujan” is his own given name, and “Srinivasa” is his father’s given name placed first as a patronymic, often written as the initial “S.” (CLM-0002). Splitting “Srinivasa Ramanujan” at the last space would code “Ramanujan” as a family name and “Srinivasa” as his given name, which is wrong. `identity.name_parts` therefore codes given “Ramanujan” and places the patronymic “Srinivasa” in the required family element with `family_first` true, so the C-CDA name reads in his own order, `<family>Srinivasa</family><given>Ramanujan</given>`, and the FHIR name has given “Ramanujan,” family “Srinivasa,” and `text` “Srinivasa Ramanujan.” Neither standard has a plain patronymic element, so the family slot holds the inherited-position name, as receiving systems expect a family value. The notes call him “Mr. Ramanujan,” the form his contemporaries used and the given name by which Tamil usage addresses a person (SOC-007). The alias “S. Ramanujan” appears in no other record; “Ramanujan” alone was not made an alias.
  3. What could not be verified and was left out. Kanigel’s book The Man Who Knew Infinity and Young’s full article were not read. The roster’s “severe vitamin deficiency” as a treated diagnosis rests only on Wikipedia; the Oxford DNB lists vitamin deficiency among diagnoses advanced later, so CLM-0012 records it as an R claim, not as treatment he received. Details of the suicide attempt beyond the Oxford DNB’s words (a train driver stopping, an arrest, police released at Hardy’s request) come from later recollection quoted in secondary pages and are not used. Wartime rationing is described in the cited sources only as making his foods harder to get, and is stated that way. The lives of his wife and family, and his religious practice in detail, are not used.
  4. Conflicts. Death place: Kumbakonam (MacTutor) or Madras (Oxford DNB); CLM-0015 keeps both and the record does not choose. Fellowship of Trinity College: 10 October 1918 (MacTutor; Wikipedia gives 13 October); the claim gives the month. The operation: April 1909 after an illness in 1908 (MacTutor; Wikipedia describes a hydrocele operation in January 1910); PMH-003 uses MacTutor. The dysentery dates are approximate (“11 and 8 years before” his illness in England), so PMH-002 is dated about 1906 with year precision. The diagnosis itself is the main conflict: tuberculosis (CLM-0010, what his physicians provisionally accepted) against hepatic amoebiasis (CLM-0011, Young 1994), with other proposals (CLM-0012). All three are R and “disputed” or “possible,” and the modern record does not settle them.
  5. Index age and dates. The index visit on January 12, 2026 maps to January 12, 1917, when he was 29, in Cambridge. The roster suggested 29 or 30 at the start of the illness. The illness is documented from 1917, with admission to a nursing hostel in May 1917 and sanatoria and nursing homes until March 1919, so a modern outpatient episode spread over 2026 would place clinic visits during those stays. The schedule was therefore compressed: all seven visits, January 12 to April 20, 2026, map to January 12 to April 20, 1917, before the nursing hostel admission. The synthetic date of birth is December 22, 1996 (shift 109 years). The ultrasound on January 13, 2026 maps to the next day. A small tension remains: MacTutor and IMSc say his health was reasonably good during his first three years (to about April 1917), and the modern symptoms begin in December; this is the cost of placing the episode before the documented stays, and it is synthetic. Past medical history includes only smallpox (1889), the dysentery (about 1906, with a second episode later) and the 1909 operation. No family history is recorded: his parents’ health is not documented in the cited sources.
  6. The single modern diagnosis. The synthetic diagnosis is an amebic liver abscess, chosen because it fits the documented history better as a teaching case: dysentery years earlier in South India, fevers, and a liver-centered illness, the clues Young emphasized; and because it lets the episode teach the step that history missed, testing for tuberculosis and amebiasis side by side. Tuberculosis is not ignored: the IGRA is positive, active disease is excluded by the radiograph, three smears, NAAT and cultures, and the latent infection is treated with four months of rifampin. The modern result is synthetic and does not decide what he had.
  7. Following the presenting-problem pattern. Intake records fever (R50.9), weight loss (R63.4) and right upper quadrant pain (R10.11), resolved at the second visit when the ultrasound and serology gave the diagnosis (A06.4 recorded then). The positive IGRA (R76.12) is recorded at the second visit and resolved at six weeks, when negative cultures allowed the diagnosis of latent infection (Z22.7). The B12 and vitamin D deficiencies and the adjustment disorder are known at intake from that day’s results and interview.
  8. Synthetic clinical picture. All laboratory values, imaging, cultures, medicines, scores and vital signs are synthetic. Qualitative results (radiograph, ultrasound, serology, stool tests, blood cultures, smears, NAAT, cultures, IGRA, HIV and hepatitis tests, hepatitis A antibody) appear only in note text. Height (165 cm) and weights are synthetic; the eGFR uses CKD-EPI 2021 without a race term.
  9. Culture and diet. The diet plan works inside his rules: lacto-vegetarian protein from pulses and dairy, B12 from dairy, fortified foods and a supplement, batch cooking once a day, foods he already eats, and an Indian grocery delivery. Medicines were checked for animal-derived ingredients: the vitamin D tablet has no gelatin and its lanolin source was explained with an alternative; the paromomycin capsule shell is gelatin, and he chose, after discussion, to take it as prescribed. The record attributes no religious ruling to him.
  10. Mood, isolation and safety. The loneliness and absence of letters from home are documented (CLM-0007, sensitive). The modern PHQ-9 of 12 and the adjustment disorder are synthetic; because the code is F43.21 and the PHQ-9 is 10 or more, `clinical.safety_assessment` is present, records no ideation, and includes the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline; safety is reviewed at every later visit, including the sick and preventive visits. The reported suicide attempt (CLM-0014, R, possible, sensitive) is history only: it is dated after the modern episode, linked only to its timeline event, absent from the intake documents and the care plan, and written without method detail beyond the source’s own words.
  11. Setting. The roster places him as a student far from home in England. The record follows the project’s U.S. conventions (SSN, CPT, CDC and USPSTF guidance, the 988 Lifeline), so the modern setting is left unnamed (“a university here”); the elements that matter for teaching, a young man from South India far from his family, are kept. The 988 Lifeline is replaced by a crisis contact in India for his trip.
  12. Real people. His parents, his wife, G. H. Hardy and D. A. B. Young appear only in documented history and the retrospective claims. In the modern episode his wife and family are mentioned only as people he calls and will visit; no modern decision, statement or health fact is attributed to any real person.
  13. Sick visit. A same-day visit for a viral upper respiratory infection three weeks into rifampin and six weeks after the abscess treatment, chosen because any fever after a liver abscess raises the question of relapse: the examination, white count, alkaline phosphatase and a CRP of 11 mg/L answer it without imaging, and rifampin continues. It insinuates no real diagnosis.
  14. Preventive visit. A periodic adult preventive visit at 29 (CPT 99395 with 99497 in plain text), with pre-travel advice for a visit to South India: injectable typhoid vaccine (the oral live vaccine is avoided with rifampin), hepatitis A antibody checked (positive at the next visit), malaria advice from a travel clinic, Tdap and the first hepatitis B dose; HPV vaccination declined after shared decision-making; lipid screening due.
  15. Focused visits. The four follow-ups (two days, twelve days, six weeks and three months) are documented as focused visits on the CDC and OFID amebiasis guidance, the ATS/IDSA/CDC tuberculosis diagnosis and treatment guidelines, the NTCA/CDC 2020 latent infection guideline, the CMID anemia and depression monographs, and the VA/DoD suicide-risk guideline. One deviation is recorded instead of an invented result: the reticulocyte count one week after starting vitamin B12 (CMID anemia monograph) was not ordered; the rising hemoglobin at twelve days and six weeks and a normal neurologic examination showed no harm, and the replacement order set now includes it. Repeat liver imaging is recorded as not indicated with clinical recovery.
  16. Consultation. The infectious diseases referral and consultation by Priya Raghunathan, MD (a fictional consultant), on the day of the second visit, are S. The consultant answers the six referral questions in line with what the record shows afterwards: an amebic rather than pyogenic abscess, and active tuberculosis very unlikely (confirmed by negative cultures at six weeks); no aspiration (fever gone by day 3); metronidazole then paromomycin without overlap (done); latent infection treated with four months of rifampin once cultures were negative and liver tests normal (started at six weeks, by message with the consultant); no tuberculosis notification and no contact screening; no repeat imaging (none done).

Protocol deviations

Checks the monitoring protocol called for that the schedule did not perform. Each is recorded with its outcome and corrective action, never filled with an invented result.

VisitMeasureIntervalWhat happened
2026-01-26
Progress note 03 (C-CDA)
Response to vitamin B12 replacementReticulocyte count at 1 week; blood count at about 8 weeks; neurologic examination at diagnosisMissed: the reticulocyte count one week after starting B12 was not ordered. No harm judging by the rising hemoglobin today (11.6 from 11.2 g/dL) and a normal neurologic examination. Corrective action: none needed for this course; the blood count at about eight weeks confirms the response, and the replacement order set now includes the reticulocyte count

Orders and referrals without results in the record

VisitTypeItemStatusDetail
2026-04-06
Progress note 06 (C-CDA)
PreventionHepatitis A immunity before travelOrderedAntibody sent today; vaccine before travel if not immune

Evidence to check

Retrospective claims (R)

ClaimStatementCertainty
CLM-0010Retrospective interpretation: his illness in England was tuberculosis, as his physicians provisionally concluded.disputed
CLM-0011Retrospective interpretation: in 1994 D. A. B. Young, reviewing his medical history, proposed that the illness was hepatic amoebiasis, a liver infection following his earlier dysentery, then regarded as a tropical disease and hard to diagnose, and treatable once diagnosed.disputed
CLM-0012Retrospective interpretation: other diagnoses advanced over the years include vitamin deficiency, lead poisoning and cancer.possible
CLM-0014Retrospective account: in the period of his illness, ill health, the absence of letters from home and loneliness are said to have driven him to a suicide attempt in the London Underground, from which he came away with only a bloodied shin. The account rests on later recollection; the date is given as late 1917 or early 1918.possible

Sensitive claims

ClaimGradeStatement
CLM-0007DIn wartime England he was lonely, and letters from home were often absent.
CLM-0014RRetrospective account: in the period of his illness, ill health, the absence of letters from home and loneliness are said to have driven him to a suicide attempt in the London Underground, from which he came away with only a bloodied shin. The account rests on later recollection; the date is given as late 1917 or early 1918.

Diagnoses not confirmed

None.

Notes to read

Every note in the record, with its type. All clinical content is synthetic.

Abnormal results

DateResultValueFlag
2026-01-12White blood cells13.6 10*3/uL (high)High
2026-01-12Hemoglobin11.2 g/dL (low)Low
2026-01-12Platelets412 10*3/uL (high)High
2026-01-12C-reactive protein92 mg/L (high)High
2026-01-12Sodium134 mmol/L (low)Low
2026-01-12Alkaline phosphatase214 U/L (high)High
2026-01-12ALT46 U/L (high)High
2026-01-12Albumin3.2 g/dL (low)Low
2026-01-12Vitamin B12168 pg/mL (low)Low
2026-01-1225-hydroxyvitamin D9 ng/mL (low)Low
2026-01-26Hemoglobin11.6 g/dL (low)Low
2026-01-26C-reactive protein24 mg/L (high)High
2026-01-26Alkaline phosphatase168 U/L (high)High
2026-02-23Hemoglobin12.6 g/dL (low)Low
2026-02-23C-reactive protein6 mg/L (high)High
2026-03-16C-reactive protein11 mg/L (high)High