SYNTHETIC RECORD, NOT A REAL MEDICAL RECORD
SYNTHETIC RECORD, NOT A REAL MEDICAL RECORD — Infectious Diseases Consultation — Florence Nightingale — True-date frame: synthetic events are moved into the patient's historical lifetime. Codes, instruments, and treatments remain modern and are anachronistic.
| Patient | Florence Nightingale |
|---|
| Date of birth | 1820-05-12 |
|---|
| Identifiers | MRN HR-NI004-SYN-TD; SSN (made up) 000-04-9271 |
|---|
| Document date | 1858-03-16 |
|---|
| Author | Daniel Abernathy, MD |
|---|
| Custodian | St. Posthumous Health Center |
|---|
Readable copy of the C-CDA narrative, generated with the XML. Coded entries are in the XML file beside this page.
Reason for Referral
Suspected post-infectious ME/CFS in a 37-year-old nurse administrator who was treated for brucellosis abroad. Before we attribute her symptoms to ME/CFS, please assess for relapsed or focal brucellosis or another persisting infection. [S]
Urgency: Routine, within two weeks. [S]
Questions for the consultant:
- Is there any clinical or laboratory evidence of relapsed brucellosis or a focal complication such as spondylitis, sacroiliitis, or endocarditis?
- Would repeat Brucella serology or blood cultures help now?
- Is any other infection related to her field-hospital work worth excluding?
- Is there any role for further antibiotics?
History of Present Illness
Ms. Nightingale is seen at the request of Dr. Marchetti. Nearly three years ago, on an overseas field-hospital deployment, she had several weeks of high fever, drenching sweats, and generalized aches; a Brucella agglutination titer was reported positive, and she completed six weeks of doxycycline with rifampin. The fever never returned. She has had no night sweats, weight loss, localized back or hip pain, or joint swelling since, and no unpasteurized dairy since returning. What persists is fatigue worsened by activity with delayed post-exertional malaise, unrefreshing sleep, cognitive difficulty, and lightheadedness on standing. Occupational tuberculosis screening on her return was negative, and she reports no needle-stick injuries. [S]
Historical basis. These claims are historical evidence, not findings from a modern examination.
- Florence Nightingale was born on May 12, 1820, in Florence, Italy, where her parents were on a European tour; her elder sister, Frances Parthenope, was born in 1819. [D]
- In October 1854 she led a party of thirty-eight nurses from London to the British military hospitals at Scutari, arriving in November 1854. [D]
- In May 1855, a few days after crossing to Balaclava to inspect the hospitals in the Crimea, she fell ill with what the army doctors called Crimean fever. She was carried to the Castle Hospital, was dangerously ill and, by her own later account, very near to death; she was reported out of danger on May 24 and made a slow and painful recovery before returning to work at Scutari. [D]
- Modern writers have interpreted her Crimean fever as brucellosis and her long later illness as chronic brucellosis. [R]
- She returned to England in the summer of 1856, emaciated and tense, and pressed for a royal commission on the health of the army, which was established in 1857. [D]
- In 1857, while working on her report for the commission, she was overworking and in failing health; she sought rest at Malvern in August and September and again in December, but would not stop working. She collapsed with cardiac symptoms so severe that it was thought she would die, and afterward suffered from nausea, insomnia, and palpitations. On her doctors' orders she took to her bed or couch but continued to work, the beginning of about twenty years of invalidism. [D]
- Her own 830-page report, Notes on Matters Affecting the Health, Efficiency, and Hospital Administration of the British Army (1858), used statistical evidence to show how much army mortality was due to conditions in the hospitals. She was elected to the Statistical Society, the first woman member. [D]
- Her prolonged illness has also been read retrospectively as what is now called myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome, while other writers have proposed neurasthenia, a psychosomatic illness, or illness used to secure time for work. [R]
4 later historical claims are omitted because they describe events after the index age. See the teaching note.
Allergies and Intolerances
| Allergy | Reaction | Status | Evidence |
|---|
| No known allergy | | active | S |
Medications
| Medication | Frequency | Route | Dates | Status | Evidence |
|---|
| Acetaminophen 500 mg oral tablet, one to two tablets by mouth every 6 hours as needed for muscle pain or headache, no more than 3 g a day | One to two tablets by mouth every 6 hours as needed; no more than 3 g a day | Oral route | 1857-11-03 | active | S |
| Cholecalciferol (vitamin D3) 50 mcg (2,000 units) oral tablet, one tablet by mouth daily | One tablet by mouth daily | Oral route | 1858-03-16 | active | S |
Problems
| Problem | Clinical status | Verification | Code | Provenance |
| Myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome, post-infectious, moderate severity, with orthostatic intolerance; synthetic modern diagnosis by NICE and IOM criteria, linked to her documented Crimean fever and decades of illness, which are only retrospectively and disputedly read as ME/CFS | active | confirmed |
G93.32 | S — Synthetic diagnosis made by clinical criteria after exclusion tests in the modern episode; the historical reading of her illness as ME/CFS remains R and disputed. |
| Personal history of brucellosis diagnosed by serology during an overseas field-hospital deployment and treated with six weeks of doxycycline and rifampin; no evidence of relapse | active | confirmed |
Z86.19 | S — Synthetic history echoing the disputed retrospective interpretation of her Crimean fever as brucellosis; not a historical diagnosis. |
| Vitamin D deficiency | active | confirmed |
E55.9 | S — Synthetic finding on the intake tests, reviewed at the two-week visit. |
Physical Exam
Vital signs recorded on 1858-03-16; see the referring visit's Vital Signs section. [S]
| System | Finding |
|---|
| General | Alert, articulate, afebrile; prefers to sit reclined |
| Lymph nodes | No lymphadenopathy |
| Heart | Regular rhythm; no murmur |
| Abdomen | No liver or spleen enlargement |
| Musculoskeletal | No spinal percussion tenderness; sacroiliac stress tests negative; no joint swelling or synovitis |
Assessment
- Personal history of treated brucellosis (Z86.19). No evidence of relapse or a focal complication. Relapses usually come within months of treatment and present with fever, which she has not had; she has no spinal or sacroiliac findings, no murmur, no organ enlargement, and normal inflammatory markers and blood count. [S]
- Repeat testing. Brucella agglutinating antibodies can stay positive for a long time after successful treatment, so a repeat titer cannot separate past from active infection and would only cause confusion. Blood cultures are useful only if fever returns. [S]
- Other infections. Nothing in her exposures calls for further infection testing now. The one-time HIV, hepatitis B, and hepatitis C screening recommended for all adults is reasonable to complete with her preventive care. [S]
- Post-infectious ME/CFS (G93.32). Her course fits a post-infectious fatigue syndrome after brucellosis rather than ongoing infection. Prolonged or repeated antibiotics do not help post-infectious fatigue and carry real harms. [S]
Data reviewed: The intake exclusion tests reviewed this morning: normal blood count, metabolic panel, liver tests, ESR 8 mm/h, CRP 1.2 mg/L, creatine kinase, and morning cortisol; 25-hydroxyvitamin D low at 17 ng/mL. The intake standing test. The report of the positive Brucella titer and the treatment record from abroad. [S]
Plan of Treatment
- No further antibiotics. [S]
- No repeat Brucella serology. [S]
- If a temperature of 38 °C or more lasts longer than three days, or night sweats or new localized back, hip, or joint pain appear, draw two sets of blood cultures and call me; spinal MRI only if focal back pain develops. [S]
- Complete one-time HIV, hepatitis B, and hepatitis C screening at her preventive visit. [S]
- Agree with managing her symptoms as ME/CFS under Dr. Marchetti, by NICE NG206. [S]
- Discussed with Dr. Marchetti today; the patient understands the plan and the warning signs. [S]
- Follow-up: No routine infectious diseases follow-up. I will see her again if the warning signs appear. [S]