Chronos Archive seal

Review checklist: Calamity Jane (HR-NI008)

All records · Back to the record · Dossier (sources.md) · Terminology · Report a problem · Comments

Everything a reviewer needs to judge, gathered from the record. Release status: draft.

Review status

ReviewStatusReviewerDateNotes
schema validationnot_startedRun scripts/build.ps1 -Conformance.
clinical reviewnot_startedAwaiting clinician review; check the DSM-5-TR count, outpatient withdrawal management at a PAWSS of 3 with gabapentin instead of a benzodiazepine, parenteral thiamine, naltrexone with AST under three times normal and the change to the monthly injection, the FIB-4 and elastography reading, the timing of the depression reassessment, the response to the two-day return to drinking, and the dental abscess managed without opioids on naltrexone.
provenance reviewnot_startedSources: Etulain (Montana Historical Society journal, 2014), the City of Deadwood Historic Preservation Office brochure, McLaird (South Dakota History, 1994, as reproduced by SDPB) and his Encyclopedia of the Great Plains entry, Bozeman Magazine (2018, quoting 1901 newspapers) and HistoryNet (2010). McLaird's book was not read. Her 1896 pamphlet is treated as unreliable; the Hickok romance is R and disputed; the birth year is 1856, not 1852.
safe messaging reviewnot_startedSubstance use claims, the losses of her children and the reported violence are marked sensitive and recorded once each, plainly and without detail; person-first language; her drinking is described without blame or sensational language. Her clothing and work are documented social history, not a medical matter, and no gender identity is assigned. No relative or companion is named in the modern episode. The safety assessment gives the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline and covers firearm storage.

Judgment calls (dossier editorial resolutions)

  1. Legend and sources. Much of what is written about her is legend, and her 1896 pamphlet is unreliable (CLM-0008). The case relies on a Montana Historical Society journal article that draws on James McLaird's biography, McLaird's own 1994 South Dakota History article and encyclopedia entry, the City of Deadwood's historic preservation brochure, a local history article quoting 1901 newspapers, and, for 1901 only, a HistoryNet article. McLaird's 2005 book was not read and is cited only as these sources report it. No National Park Service page about her was found beyond a photograph record, so none is cited. Popular sites found in searches were not used.
  2. Birth date. The 1860 census lists her as born in 1856, and her principal biographer and the Deadwood brochure give 1856; the roster and many popular accounts give May 1, 1852, and her gravestone implied 1850. The preferred date is about 1856 (precision approximate). The Deadwood brochure's May 1, 1856 is kept as an unresolved alternative, since her biographer writes only “perhaps May 1.” The synthetic date of birth, May 1, 1981, uses the traditional month and day; the shift is 125 years.
  3. Index age and dates. The index visit on March 2, 2026 maps to March 2, 1901, when she was about 44: two days after a Butte newspaper reported her in Livingston and a few weeks after her stay at the Gallatin County poor farm. The visits on March 9, March 23, March 30, April 27, May 11 and June 22, 2026 map to the same days of 1901, when newspapers placed her in southern and central Montana (Bozeman, Livingston, and reports in Lewistown, Billings and Butte papers), before she left for Buffalo in July. The facility's town is not specified. The suggested touring years (1893 to 1896) were not used because her whereabouts then do not allow months of visits in one region: she toured the eastern states in the first months of 1896. Past medical history includes only events up to February 1901.
  4. Name. She is known as Calamity Jane, which has no family name in the usual sense; her name at birth was Martha Canary. The record uses identity.name_parts (given Martha, family Canary) so that the C-CDA and FHIR patient names carry her legal name, while the display name and the FHIR name text are Calamity Jane. The notes call her Ms. Canary after noting that she goes by Calamity Jane. Aliases are Martha Canary and Martha Jane Canary; no other record contains either. “Jane” as a middle name is common in popular accounts but is not documented in the sources read. “Jane” alone is not an alias.
  5. Clothing and work. She often wore men's clothing and did work then done mostly by men (CLM-0003). This is recorded neutrally as documented social history, not as a medical matter. No gender identity is assigned: she never stated one in any source read. The roster's “gender nonconformity stress” lead is not used.
  6. Alcohol. Her heavy drinking is documented (CLM-0009, D, sensitive); the label alcoholic is a later judgment (CLM-0010, R). The modern alcohol use disorder is synthetic. Her death is recorded as inflammation of the bowels, with pneumonia also reported (CLM-0018); the role of alcohol is a biographers' judgment (CLM-0019, R).
  7. Hickok. James Butler (Wild Bill) Hickok appears only in documented history (CLM-0005, D): the 1876 trip and his murder. The romance is legend (CLM-0006, R, disputed). Nothing is attributed to him, and he does not appear in the modern episode.
  8. Smallpox nursing. Graded D with certainty probable (CLM-0007): the Deadwood brochure and McLaird date it to 1878, and Etulain cites several memoirists, but the accounts are recollections.
  9. Tuberculosis. The roster lists TB exposure. No source read documents tuberculosis; one documents a stay in a pest house for people with communicable diseases (CLM-0013). The modern episode screens for latent tuberculosis because of shelter stays and records a negative result; no infection is claimed.
  10. Relatives and companions. Her parents, siblings, children and partners are not named in the modern episode and are given no decisions, statements or health facts. The parents' deaths, the son's death and the daughter's birth appear only as dated historical facts, and the reported violence by a partner is recorded once without detail. The modern social history says only that she has a grown daughter she has not seen for some time. No family history is recorded. The friend, the peer recovery specialist, the community health worker and the man who offered pills are synthetic and unnamed.
  11. Synthetic clinical picture. Everything in the modern episode is synthetic: the drinking history, the DSM-5-TR count, every score (AUDIT, PHQ-9, GAD-7, PC-PTSD-5, and the PAWSS and CIWA-Ar, which have no LOINC total code here and are recorded as narrative), all laboratory values, PEth, the elastography readings, the FIB-4 values (calculated from the synthetic results and recorded as narrative), the urine drug, pregnancy, HIV, hepatitis, HPV and interferon-gamma release assay results (narrative), the medicines, the lapse and the outcomes. Height (165 cm) and weights are synthetic.
  12. Clinical judgment calls. (1) Outpatient withdrawal management at a PAWSS of 3 with a support person and daily nurse checks, although her housing is unstable; hospital criteria were written down. (2) Gabapentin rather than a benzodiazepine, since she is likely to be alone at times and could return to drinking during withdrawal, and her liver tests are raised. (3) Three days of intramuscular thiamine, then oral. (4) Naltrexone with an AST under three times the upper limit, changed to the monthly extended-release injection after missed doses. (5) No antidepressant: the PHQ-9 fell from 14 to 5 after ten weeks without alcohol, and the depressive symptoms were judged alcohol-induced. (6) The first elastography reading (9.6 kPa) was treated as indeterminate because of recent inflammation and repeated at sixteen weeks (6.8 kPa). (7) The two-day return to drinking is recorded honestly, corroborated by PEth, and met without blame. (8) Naloxone was not prescribed: she uses no opioids, and the urine test showed none.
  13. Sex-specific risks. The NIAAA Core Resource is the basis for counseling that women reach higher blood alcohol levels than men from the same amount, develop liver damage sooner, and have a higher breast cancer risk with drinking; the plan includes a pregnancy test, breast and cervical screening, and contraception if needed.
  14. Social needs. Montana Medicaid, SNAP, a food bank, the Human Resource Development Councils (Montana's community action agencies, which run housing programs), Montana 211 and the federal Lifeline phone program are real public programs. No phone number other than 988 is given.
  15. Preventive visit. A periodic adult preventive visit at 44 (CPT 99396 with 99497 in plain text). Judgment calls: HIV, hepatitis C and hepatitis B screening done at intake; self-collected HPV testing offered as a trauma-informed choice (negative); mammography at a mobile unit with transport (normal); an interferon-gamma release assay for latent tuberculosis because of shelter stays (negative); a lipid panel with low risk; Tdap, the first hepatitis A and B doses and PCV20; the HPV vaccine declined; advance care planning names an unnamed friend as agent.
  16. Sick visit. A dental abscess two weeks into oral naltrexone, chosen because it fits years without dental care and tests the plan: opioids are avoided because naltrexone blocks them and attempts to overcome the block can be fatal, ibuprofen with acetaminophen (no more than 2 g a day) treats the pain, amoxicillin is given because of fever and facial swelling, and definitive dental treatment is arranged the next day. It is not a historical claim.
  17. Focused visits. The four chronic-care follow-ups (one week with the consultation, four weeks, ten weeks and sixteen weeks) are documented as focused visits on the APA 2018 guideline, the ASAM 2020 withdrawal guideline, the NIAAA Core Resource, the AASLD 2019 guidance, the CMID depression monograph and the VA/DoD suicide-risk guideline. Two deviations are recorded instead of invented results: (1) weekly peer recovery contact lapsed for about two weeks in early April when she had no phone; no harm resulted (no drinking; she kept going to her meeting), and the corrective action was a Lifeline phone and text confirmation of each call; (2) the third extended-release naltrexone injection was given four days late while she was away for work, and her two days of drinking came just before it; she stopped within two days with no withdrawal and her liver results improved, and the corrective action was scheduling injections on days she chooses, with a reminder call and a ride. Synthetic findings introduced: a CIWA-Ar of 10 on the second day of withdrawal, the missed oral doses, the indeterminate first elastography, and the two-day lapse.
  18. Consultation. The addiction medicine referral and the consultation by Dolores Two Bulls-Harmon, MD (a fictional consultant), on the day of the one-week visit, are S. The consultant answers the five referral questions in line with what the record shows afterwards: severe alcohol use disorder with withdrawal safely managed as an outpatient; naltrexone, changed to the monthly injection when tablets were missed; liver enzymes rechecked at four weeks; elastography at four weeks and again after months; the PHQ-9 at four weeks before any antidepressant; PEth at four and sixteen weeks; peer support, mutual-help choices and a plan for a return to drinking; and help with benefits and housing.

Protocol deviations

Checks the monitoring protocol called for that the schedule did not perform. Each is recorded with its outcome and corrective action, never filled with an invented result.

VisitMeasureIntervalWhat happened
2026-05-11
Progress note 06 (C-CDA)
Peer recovery support and mutual-help meetingsWeekly peer contact; meetings of her choiceNo peer contact for about two weeks in early April, when she had no phone. No harm resulted: she did not drink, and she went to her Thursday meeting. Corrective action: a free Lifeline phone was arranged, and the peer specialist now confirms each week's call by text
2026-06-22
Progress note 07 (C-CDA)
Medicine for alcohol use disorder: adherence, side effects, opioid exposureEvery four weeks, on timeThe third injection was given four days late because she was away for work, and the two days of drinking came just before it. No lasting harm: she stopped within two days, had no withdrawal, and her liver tests and elastography improved. Corrective action: injections are booked on days she chooses, with a reminder call and a ride from the peer specialist

Orders and referrals without results in the record

VisitTypeItemStatusDetail
2026-03-09
Progress note 02 (C-CDA)
ImagingLiver fibrosis: FIB-4, transient elastography, albumin, INR, plateletsOrderedFIB-4 3.93 at intake; transient elastography booked for the four-week visit
2026-04-27
Progress note 05 (C-CDA)
PreventionBreast cancer screeningOrderedMammography every two years from 40; ordered at the mobile unit, with transport arranged
2026-04-27
Progress note 05 (C-CDA)
PreventionLatent tuberculosis screeningOrderedInterferon-gamma release assay today; she has stayed in shelters

Evidence to check

Retrospective claims (R)

ClaimStatementCertainty
CLM-0006Stories of a romance or marriage between her and Hickok are legend; her biographers find that they were acquaintances for a few weeks and that no evidence supports a love affair.disputed
CLM-0010Historians describe her as an alcoholic; a diagnosis in present-day terms cannot be made from the historical record.probable
CLM-0016By 1901 a writer who met her in Livingston thought she had aged far beyond her years from heavy drinking and poor nutrition.probable
CLM-0019Her biographers judge that years of heavy drinking contributed to her death.probable

Sensitive claims

ClaimGradeStatement
CLM-0009DNewspapers and contemporaries repeatedly reported her heavy drinking from the 1870s on; she was arrested for intoxication and disorderly conduct, and her principal biographer writes that every effort to end her drinking failed. Her drinking, wandering and lack of money left her poor even in settled periods.
CLM-0010RHistorians describe her as an alcoholic; a diagnosis in present-day terms cannot be made from the historical record.
CLM-0011DShe gave birth to a son in 1882 who died soon after birth, and to a daughter in 1887.
CLM-0012DIn the mid-1880s, newspapers in Rawlins, Wyoming, reported that a man she lived with, and later married, beat her and stole from her.
CLM-0016RBy 1901 a writer who met her in Livingston thought she had aged far beyond her years from heavy drinking and poor nutrition.
CLM-0017DIn July 1901 a New York writer brought her to the Pan-American Exposition in Buffalo, where binge drinking got her into trouble, and she returned west late that year.
CLM-0019RHer biographers judge that years of heavy drinking contributed to her death.

Diagnoses not confirmed

ProblemCodeVerificationReason
Depressive symptoms during heavy drinking (PHQ-9 14, item 9 scored 0); whether they are alcohol-induced or an independent depression to be judged after two to four weeks without alcoholF32.AprovisionalSynthetic provisional finding; resolved as the PHQ-9 fell to 5 after ten weeks without alcohol, consistent with alcohol-induced depressive symptoms. Not a claim about her real mood.

Notes to read

Every note in the record, with its type. All clinical content is synthetic.

Abnormal results

DateResultValueFlag
2026-03-02MCV103 fL (high)High
2026-03-02Sodium134 mmol/L (low)Low
2026-03-02Potassium3.3 mmol/L (low)Low
2026-03-02Magnesium1.5 mg/dL (low)Low
2026-03-02Phosphate2.4 mg/dL (low)Low
2026-03-02Albumin3.4 g/dL (low)Low
2026-03-02AST96 U/L (high)High
2026-03-02ALT44 U/L (high)High
2026-03-02GGT240 U/L (high)High
2026-03-02Folate3.2 ng/mL (low)Low
2026-03-02PEth820 ng/mL (high)High
2026-03-30AST48 U/L (high)High
2026-03-30GGT132 U/L (high)High
2026-03-30PEth24 ng/mL (high)High
2026-03-30Liver stiffness (transient elastography)9.6 kPa (high)High
2026-06-22GGT58 U/L (high)High
2026-06-22PEth64 ng/mL (high)High