SYNTHETIC RECORD, NOT A REAL MEDICAL RECORD

Review checklist: Geronimo (HR-NI016)
All records · Back to the record · Dossier (sources.md) · Terminology · Report a problem · Comments
Everything a reviewer needs to judge, gathered from the record. Release status: draft.
- 26judgment calls in the dossier
- 1protocol deviations
- 3orders and referrals without results in the record
- 5evidence items to check (retrospective or sensitive claims, unconfirmed diagnoses)
Review status
| Review | Status | Reviewer | Date | Notes |
|---|
| schema validation | not_started | | | Run scripts/build.ps1 -Conformance. |
| clinical review | not_started | | | Awaiting clinician review; check the CAPS-5 decision and the decision that prolonged grief disorder criteria are not met, cognitive processing therapy without the written account for a man who does not read English, sertraline at 25 then 50 mg with the sodium check done at five rather than two to four weeks, the decision not to start prazosin now, naltrexone with AST under three times normal, and the vaccines given at 77. |
| provenance review | not_started | | | Sources: two National Park Service pages (Chiricahua National Monument), the Oklahoma Historical Society encyclopedia, the National Archives at Riverside, his own autobiography as told to S. M. Barrett (Project Gutenberg), and an Oklahoma Gazette feature for his last illness. Angie Debo's biography, the Smithsonian NMAI, the Fort Sill museum and a Fort Bowie page were not read. The year of the killings at Kas-ki-yeh is disputed (1850, 1851, 1858). |
| safe messaging review | not_started | | | Ceremony and spiritual power are not medicalized: his belief that he would not die by a gun is recorded as religion and is not coded; traditional healing is offered without probing. The killings, wounds and captivity are recorded once each, plainly. Alcohol and grief claims are marked sensitive. No relative is named, and no relative or historical person is given a statement or decision in the modern episode. The safety assessment gives the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline. |
Judgment calls (dossier editorial resolutions)
- Sources. The case relies on two National Park Service pages (Chiricahua National Monument), the Oklahoma Historical Society encyclopedia, the National Archives at Riverside, his own autobiography as told to S. M. Barrett (public domain, read in full from Project Gutenberg), and an Oklahoma Gazette feature for the circumstances of his last illness, which the National Park Service corroborates. Angie Debo's biography was not read, and no reliable source quoting it was found, so nothing in the record rests on it. The Smithsonian National Museum of the American Indian, the Fort Sill National Historic Landmark and Museum, and a Fort Bowie National Historic Site page (the address tried returned not found) were not read. Popular and fan sites found in searches were not used. No Apache-authored source other than his own dictated account was read.
- Recent-death rule. He died in 1909, so the rule does not apply. A sick visit is included.
- Birth date. He gave June 1829 and No-doyohn Cañon; the National Park Service gives the Gila River in New Mexico near the Gila Cliff Dwellings without a year; the Oklahoma Historical Society gives the 1820s, perhaps near Clifton, Arizona. The preferred birth is June 1829 (precision month), with the 1820s kept as an unresolved alternative. A day of June 16 appears on popular sites but not in any source read and is not used. Because the day is unknown, the synthetic date of birth uses June 1 as a placeholder: 1949-06-01, a shift of 120 years. The true-date variant therefore places his birth on June 1, 1829, a modeling artifact, not a claim.
- Index age and dates. He is 77 at the index visit on July 8, 2026, which maps to July 8, 1906, at Fort Sill, where he was held as a prisoner of war and where he dictated his autobiography in 1905 and 1906 (the editor's letters are dated at Fort Sill from August 1905). The visits on July 22, August 19, September 2, September 23, October 7 and October 28, 2026 map to the same days of 1906, within his lifetime. His day-to-day whereabouts in those months are not documented in the sources read; his travels under guard to expositions (1898, 1901, 1904) and the 1905 inauguration fall outside the episode. Past medical history includes only events before the index date. The 1909 death claim is linked only to the 1909 timeline event and is omitted from intake documents.
- Name. He is known as Geronimo, a single name, and has no family name in the Western sense. identity.name_parts places the single name in the family-name field with an empty given-name list, as cases/HR-NI015-sitting-bull does: the C-CDA carries the required given-name element as a null flavor, the FHIR name has no given part, and the FHIR name text and display name are “Geronimo.” The notes call him Geronimo, as he asked in the modern episode, never “Mr. Geronimo.” His birth name is spelled Goyakla by the National Park Service and Goyahkla by the Oklahoma Historical Society; both are aliases and appear in no other record. The form Goyaałé, used by some library and language references, was not confirmed in a reliable source that could be read (one library cooperative page was blocked) and is not used. Barrett's spelling of the interpreter's name, Asa Deklugie, is kept, with the common spelling Daklugie noted.
- Medicine man and spiritual power. The National Park Service calls him “a medicine man”; that phrase appears only as quoted in CLM-0002. His belief that Usen told him he would never die in battle or by a gun (CLM-0003) is recorded as religious history. It is not interpreted, coded or treated as a symptom, and it is not linked to his drinking or his last illness. No ceremony is described in the modern episode; traditional healing is offered through the clinic's traditional medicine program at his choice, and the clinic asks nothing about his practices, following IHS policy. Ceremonial tobacco is not asked about; only commercial tobacco is.
- The killings at Kas-ki-yeh. That Mexican troops killed his mother, his wife and his three children is documented by his own account and by the National Archives and the Oklahoma Historical Society (CLM-0004, D, probable). The year is disputed: 1858 in his own account, 1851 by the National Archives, 1850 by the Oklahoma Historical Society; the National Park Service gives no year and says “one of his wives” and “some of his children.” The assignment's lead of Janos and 1851 or 1858 is reflected only through these sources: his own account names the town Kas-ki-yeh and does not name Janos, and no source read identifies Kas-ki-yeh with Janos, so Janos is not used. The timeline uses 1851 (National Archives) with the other years in its display text. The family history records the mother and the three children as killed in an attack (not a medical cause of death); the wife is a spouse and is not entered in the family history, but appears in the claim and the past medical history.
- His own words about grief. CLM-0005 quotes his description of the night of the killings and the time after (sensitive). It is history, not a retrospective diagnosis. The editor's footnote that by custom the property of deceased relatives was not kept is recorded so that burning his family's belongings is read as mourning practice, not as a symptom.
- Wounds and head injury. His own list of eight wounds (it names seven) is recorded in the past medical history (CLM-0006), including a bullet he still carried in the right thigh and a blow to the head that knocked him senseless. No lasting effect is documented. The modern episode notes the scars and uses the old head injury only as one reason for a Mini-Cog; no retained-fragment work-up or brain injury diagnosis is added, since no source documents a lasting problem.
- Captivity. The surrender in 1886, hard labor at Fort Pickens apart from his family, the deaths of many Chiricahua prisoners from malaria and tuberculosis, and his status as a prisoner of war at Fort Sill (CLM-0007 to CLM-0009) are recorded as history and social history. In the modern frame he lives on the military reservation near Fort Sill under federal restrictions on travel; this is a synthetic rendering of his documented status, not a claim about any modern detention. No code is assigned for his custody or social circumstances. The inauguration of 1905 is recorded as “a presidential inauguration parade” without naming the president, who has his own record in the dataset.
- Alcohol. His own statement that he was twice jailed in the guardhouse for drinking whisky as a prisoner of war (CLM-0012) anchors the synthetic moderate alcohol use disorder (F10.20); it is marked sensitive and is not a retrospective diagnosis. The 1909 drinking, fall and pneumonia (CLM-0014, sensitive) are history after the episode, recorded plainly. The modern fall (PRB-004) is synthetic and is not the fall of 1909; the sick-visit bronchitis is not the pneumonia of 1909; neither is presented as foreshadowing or as a claim that modern care would have changed the outcome.
- Diagnoses and presenting problem. Poor sleep with nightmares and intrusive memories (G47.00) is the presenting problem, resolved at the consultation when chronic post-traumatic stress disorder (F43.12) was confirmed on the CAPS-5. Both F43.12 and F10.20 are placed both_with_link, because each is a synthetic modern diagnosis anchored to documented history. The roster's PTSD and traumatic grief leads are kept as one R claim (CLM-0015, possible) and are not made historical diagnoses.
- Prolonged grief disorder. Considered and not diagnosed (judgment call): his grief is lasting but not the near-daily, consuming yearning or preoccupation that DSM-5-TR requires, and his mourning follows the customs of his people, which the criteria say must be exceeded. The distress that brought him in is attributed to post-traumatic stress. This avoids turning mourning into a disorder.
- CAPS-5 and instruments. The CAPS-5 has no LOINC code on the terminology server; its result (criteria met in all four clusters, severity 44) is recorded as narrative. The PC-PTSD-5 (102017-1), PCL-5 (101698-9), AUDIT (75624-7), PHQ-2, PHQ-9, Mini-Cog (72233-0) and PEth (74661-0) are coded. The Timed Up and Go is narrative. Instruments were given aloud through the interpreter; the PCL-5 and AUDIT have not been validated in Chiricahua Apache, which is a limit of the scores, noted here.
- Prazosin. The assignment said prazosin is not recommended for nightmares by the VA/DoD 2023 guideline. The guideline's Quick Reference Guide shows the opposite for nightmares: recommendation 32 suggests prazosin for nightmares associated with PTSD (weak for), while recommendation 18 suggests against prazosin for PTSD overall. The record follows the guideline as published. Prazosin is not started (judgment call) because of orthostatic falls risk in a man of 77 who had just fallen and was drinking, and it is to be reconsidered with standing blood pressures if nightmares persist; by sixteen weeks it was not needed.
- Therapy and medicine choices. Cognitive processing therapy was chosen over prolonged exposure because it can be delivered without a written trauma account, its worksheets can be done aloud through an interpreter, and it does not require detailed retelling, which he declined (judgment call). He chose to start therapy first and sertraline four weeks later; sertraline began at 25 mg and rose to 50 mg; paroxetine was avoided at his age; venlafaxine was the alternative. No benzodiazepine was used. The therapist follows his lead on how to speak of those who died; the record does not assert a specific custom about naming the dead, because no source read documents one.
- Naltrexone. Started at the consultation with AST under three times the upper limit, normal kidney function and a urine test negative for opioids; acamprosate was the documented alternative. No withdrawal medicine was given because he had no history of complicated withdrawal and had cut down without symptoms (judgment call).
- Safety assessment. Required by F43.12, F10.20 and a PHQ-9 of 11. It records no suicidal thoughts, no firearm, small medicine supplies, a written safety plan and the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline, and safety is reviewed at every later visit.
- Care setting. The project facility name (St. Posthumous Health Center) is kept; in the notes it is a tribal health clinic near Fort Sill with an Apache-speaking interpreter, a behavioral health therapist, a traditional medicine program and a visiting psychiatrist. These are fictional features of a fictional clinic.
- Clinician names. “Whitehorse” appears in no other record, so the assigned primary clinician name “Roberta Whitehorse-Lindgren, MD” is used. The consultant is “Dominic Achebe-Varga, MD,” psychiatry (trauma and PTSD).
- Relatives and others. No relative is named in this record; his wives and children appear only in claims, without names. No modern statement, decision or health fact is attributed to any relative or historical person. The interpreter, the therapist, his friends, his neighbors and his health care agent are synthetic and unnamed. Military officers, the editor Barrett and the interpreter Deklugie appear only in claims. Other figures who have records in the dataset are not named.
- Synthetic clinical picture. Everything in the modern episode is synthetic: the symptoms, every score, all laboratory values, the chest X-ray, the medicines, the missed therapy session, the drinking pattern, the heavy evening and the outcomes. Height (173 cm) and weights are synthetic.
- Wellness visit. He is 77 and new to the clinic with no record of a previous wellness visit, so the visit is an initial annual wellness visit (HCPCS G0438 and CPT 99497 in plain text; visit type annual_wellness_initial, as cases/HR-ET015 uses), not the subsequent visit the batch brief names for patients of 65 and older (judgment call). Judgment calls: hepatitis C and B screening (negative; not immune to hepatitis B, vaccine offered and left to his decision); a stool immunochemical test at 77 after a discussion of the smaller benefit at his age (negative); PSA, lung cancer and aneurysm screening not indicated; no lipid test or statin at his choice, with evidence insufficient after 75; high-dose influenza, PCV20 and RSV vaccines at the wellness visit, with Tdap and the first recombinant zoster dose at the sixteen-week visit; COVID-19 vaccine declined for now; advance care planning with an unnamed agent, recording that his prayers and ways are to be respected as he directs, without describing them.
- Sick visit. Acute viral bronchitis, chosen because it interacts with his treatment and insinuates no undocumented diagnosis: a clear chest X-ray in a man of 77, no antibiotic under CDC guidance, no codeine cough syrup (blocked by naltrexone), no alcohol-containing syrup, dextromethorphan avoided with sertraline, and acetaminophen capped at 2,000 mg a day after recent heavy drinking. It is not a historical claim and not the pneumonia of 1909.
- Focused visits. The four chronic-care follow-ups (two weeks with the consultation, six weeks, eleven weeks and sixteen weeks) are documented as focused visits on the VA/DoD 2023 and APA 2017 PTSD guidelines, the CMID depression monograph, the APA alcohol use disorder guideline and NIAAA core resource, the VA/DoD suicide-risk guideline, USPSTF falls prevention and the IHS traditional medicine policy. One deviation is recorded instead of an invented result: the sodium check due two to four weeks after sertraline was started was missed (not ordered at the sick visit, the only visit in that window) and done at five weeks (137 mmol/L, no harm); the corrective action is a laboratory-only visit two weeks after any SSRI dose change and an order-set prompt. One therapy session was missed during the bronchitis and made up within the course. Synthetic findings introduced: the CAPS-5 result, the falling PCL-5 (56, 54, 46, 35, 24), the missed session, the one heavy evening, the bronchitis and the recovering liver tests.
- Consultation. The psychiatry referral and consultation by Dominic Achebe-Varga, MD (a fictional consultant), on the day of the two-week visit, are S. The consultant answers the five referral questions in line with what the record shows afterwards: chronic PTSD on the CAPS-5; prolonged grief disorder not met; cognitive processing therapy adapted for his age and language (completed in sixteen weeks); sertraline if he wished (started at six weeks), sodium in the first month (done late, recorded as a deviation), no benzodiazepines and no prazosin for now; naltrexone with liver tests (started that day; tests at six weeks); and treatment of both conditions together. The consultant's history uses only what he chose to say, and attributes nothing to any relative.
Protocol deviations
Checks the monitoring protocol called for that the schedule did not perform. Each is recorded with its outcome and corrective action, never filled with an invented result.
| Visit | Measure | Interval | What happened |
|---|
2026-09-23 Progress note 05 (C-CDA) | SSRI safety: sodium, bleeding, falls and side effects | Sodium within the first month in older adults; review at each dose change | The sodium check due two to four weeks after starting sertraline was missed: it was not ordered at the sick visit two weeks after the start, the one visit in that window. Done today at five weeks: 137 mmol/L, so no harm resulted, and he had no symptoms of low sodium. Corrective action: a laboratory-only visit is booked two weeks after any future SSRI dose change, and the clinic's SSRI order set now prompts the sodium check |
Orders and referrals without results in the record
| Visit | Type | Item | Status | Detail |
|---|
2026-07-22 Progress note 02 (C-CDA) | Self-management | Trauma-focused psychotherapy (cognitive processing therapy), sessions attended | Ordered | Cognitive processing therapy booked weekly from next week, with the interpreter |
2026-08-19 Progress note 03 (C-CDA) | Medication safety | SSRI safety: sodium, bleeding, falls and side effects | Ordered | Sertraline 25 mg started today; sodium due in two to four weeks |
2026-10-07 Progress note 06 (C-CDA) | Prevention | Colorectal cancer screening | Ordered | Ages 76 to 85: selective; never screened, and he chose a stool immunochemical test |
Evidence to check
Retrospective claims (R)
| Claim | Statement | Certainty |
|---|
| CLM-0015 | The project roster lists post-traumatic stress disorder and traumatic grief as his anchor conditions; no historical source read makes either diagnosis. | possible |
Sensitive claims
| Claim | Grade | Statement |
|---|
| CLM-0005 | D | In his own words, that night he stood alone by the river, did not vote in the council, had no weapon and hardly wished to fight, and 'had no purpose left'; on the march home he did not eat and spoke to no one. At home he burned his family's belongings, vowed vengeance, and wrote that he was never again contented in his quiet home. |
| CLM-0012 | D | In his autobiography he said that since he had been a prisoner of war he had twice been arrested and placed in the guardhouse for drinking whisky. |
| CLM-0014 | D | He died at Fort Sill on February 17, 1909, of pneumonia. On a cold February day he had ridden into Lawton and obtained whisky; returning after nightfall he fell from his horse and lay until morning near his house, partly in water. He was taken to the post hospital and died days later, aged 79 by his own reckoning, and was buried in the Apache cemetery at Fort Sill. |
| CLM-0015 | R | The project roster lists post-traumatic stress disorder and traumatic grief as his anchor conditions; no historical source read makes either diagnosis. |
Diagnoses not confirmed
None.
Notes to read
Every note in the record, with its type. All clinical content is synthetic.
- History and physical (C-CDA), 2026-07-08
- Progress note 01 (C-CDA): Initial plan, 2026-07-08
- Progress note 02 (C-CDA): Focused Visit (Follow-up), 2026-07-22
- Progress note 03 (C-CDA): Focused Visit (Follow-up), 2026-08-19
- Progress note 04 (C-CDA): Sick Visit, 2026-09-02
- Progress note 05 (C-CDA): Focused Visit (Follow-up), 2026-09-23
- Progress note 06 (C-CDA): Annual Wellness Visit, Initial, 2026-10-07
- Progress note 07 (C-CDA): Focused Visit (Care-plan review), 2026-10-28
- Referral (C-CDA) and consultation (C-CDA), Psychiatry (trauma and PTSD)
- Care plan and teaching note
Abnormal results
| Date | Result | Value | Flag |
|---|
| 2026-07-08 | Mean corpuscular volume | 101 fL (high) | High |
| 2026-07-08 | AST | 58 U/L (high) | High |
| 2026-07-08 | GGT | 112 U/L (high) | High |
| 2026-07-08 | PEth (alcohol marker) | 236 ng/mL (high) | High |
| 2026-08-19 | AST | 41 U/L (high) | High |
| 2026-08-19 | GGT | 84 U/L (high) | High |
| 2026-09-23 | GGT | 63 U/L (high) | High |
| 2026-09-23 | PEth (alcohol marker) | 41 ng/mL (high) | High |