# Rheumatology Referral

> **SYNTHETIC RECORD, NOT A REAL MEDICAL RECORD**

- Patient: Michelangelo Buonarroti (real historical name used in a fictional teaching record)
- Synthetic MRN: HR-RE002-SYN-TD
- Date: 1560-03-16
- Fictional facility: St. Posthumous Health Center
- Fictional author: Serena Castellano, MD
- Calendar frame: true historical dates (modern content is anachronistic)

> True-date frame: synthetic events are moved into the patient's historical lifetime. Codes, instruments, and treatments remain modern and are anachronistic.

- To: Paul Okeke, MD, Rheumatology
- Urgency: Routine, within four weeks

## Referral question

Painful, stiff hands in an 85-year-old working sculptor, worst at the left thumb base, with metacarpophalangeal as well as interphalangeal involvement. Please confirm osteoarthritis, exclude inflammatory, crystal, and iron-overload arthritis, and advise on a thumb-base injection and on safe pain relief that lets him keep carving. **S**

## Questions for the consultant

1. Do you agree this is osteoarthritis, and is anything else, such as calcium pyrophosphate disease, hemochromatosis, gout, or an inflammatory arthritis, contributing given the metacarpophalangeal involvement?
2. Is a glucocorticoid injection of the left thumb base appropriate, and would you perform it?
3. What pain relief is safe at 85 with gout, a past stone history, and a creatinine rise on ibuprofen?
4. What splinting, hand therapy, and tool changes do you advise so he can keep carving?
5. Does his gout need any change in treatment because of the hand symptoms?

## Pertinent history

Two years of worsening left thumb-base pain and stiffness, with knobby swelling of the left thumb and index finger; carving now limited to about two hours and writing to short notes. He had been taking ibuprofen 1200 mg a day for three months; today creatinine is 1.21 mg/dL (eGFR 59) and blood pressure 148/82, so ibuprofen was stopped and diclofenac gel, acetaminophen as needed, and a thumb-base splint started. Gout without tophi, in remission on allopurinol 200 mg, serum urate 5.4 mg/dL; urinary stones years ago, none since. Radiographs today: left first carpometacarpal osteoarthritis (Eaton stage III), narrowing and osteophytes at the left thumb and index metacarpophalangeal and interphalangeal joints, right distal interphalangeal osteophytes, no erosions or chondrocalcinosis. CRP 2.1 mg/L, ESR 18 mm/h, rheumatoid factor and anti-CCP negative, ferritin 110 ng/mL, transferrin saturation 28%. Pain 7 of 10; PROMIS upper extremity T-score 33; grip 14 kg left, 22 kg right. **S**

- Michelangelo was born at Caprese on March 6, 1475, by the modern reckoning; his father's notebook records the birth as March 6, 1474, in the Florentine style, on a Monday morning before daybreak. **D**
- In 1548 he wrote to his nephew that he had lately been in great difficulty from dysuria but was better. **D**
- In a letter to his nephew dated March 15, 1549, he wrote that he had been very ill with dysuria, groaning in pain night and day without sleep, that his doctors thought he was suffering from calculus, and that he had been advised to try the baths at Viterbo. **D**
- On March 23, 1549, he wrote that after drinking a water sent to him he passed a large quantity of thick white matter with portions of the shell of the stone, and was much better. **D**
- On April 5, 1549, he wrote that it was now quite certain that he had urinary calculus, not very advanced, and that it was gradually diminishing with the water he was drinking. **D**
- In a letter the editor dates to June 8, 1549, he wrote that for about two months he had drunk, morning and evening, a water from a spring about forty miles from Rome that breaks up the stone, that it had broken his and let him pass water with tolerable ease, and that he would have to use nothing else for drinking or cooking and alter his mode of life. **D**
- On June 16, 1557, he wrote to his nephew that he suffered from all the ailments of old age: the stone, so that he could not pass water, and pains in his side and back, so that he often could not go up or down stairs. **D**
- A postscript to a letter of 1559 (dated June 15; the editor notes the nephew altered it to July 15) reads: writing is very troublesome to my hand, my eyes and my memory; such is the effect of age. **D**
- Lazzeri and colleagues (2016), studying portraits, proposed that degenerative, non-inflammatory osteoarthritis affected the base of his left thumb, the thumb's metacarpophalangeal and interphalangeal joints, and the index finger's metacarpophalangeal and proximal interphalangeal joints; earlier portraits show no deformity, and they place the onset around 1547 to 1553, with worsening in his last fifteen years. **R**
- The same authors report that letters to his nephew speak of gout, a period term for many arthritic conditions, and of a cruel pain in one foot; they judged gouty arthritis of the hands unlikely because the portraits show no inflammation or tophi. **R**
- His father, Lodovico, was born on June 11, 1444, and died in 1533 or 1534; Michelangelo's poem on his death says he was ninety. **D**
- He had two acute illnesses, the first in the summer of 1544 and the second toward the close of 1545, when news reached Florence that he was dying; he recovered from both. **D**

3 later historical claims are omitted because they describe events after the index age. See the teaching note.

Baseline: Sodium: 138 mmol/L; Potassium: 4.9 mmol/L; Bicarbonate (total CO2): 24 mmol/L; BUN: 26 mg/dL (high); Creatinine: 1.21 mg/dL; eGFR: 59 mL/min/1.73 m² (low); Glucose: 92 mg/dL; Serum urate: 5.4 mg/dL; Hemoglobin: 13.6 g/dL; White cell count: 6.2 10*3/uL; Platelets: 224 10*3/uL; ALT: 18 U/L; Calcium: 9.4 mg/dL; 25-hydroxyvitamin D: 34 ng/mL; CRP: 2.1 mg/L; ESR: 18 mm/h; Rheumatoid factor: 8 [IU]/mL; Anti-CCP antibody: 3 U/mL; Ferritin: 110 ng/mL; Transferrin saturation: 28%; Hand pain (0-10 numeric rating): 7; PROMIS upper extremity T-score: 33; Grip strength, left hand: 14 kg; Grip strength, right hand: 22 kg. All results are synthetic.

BP 148/82 mmHg; pulse 72 bpm; respirations 16/min; temperature 36.6 °C; oxygen saturation 97% on room air; weight 62 kg; BMI 22 kg/m². All vital signs are synthetic.

## Current medications

- Allopurinol 100 mg oral tablet, two tablets (200 mg) by mouth daily **S**
- Diclofenac sodium 1% topical gel, 2 g to the painful hand joints four times daily, no more than 8 g a day to either hand **S**
- Acetaminophen 500 mg oral tablet, two tablets by mouth up to three times daily as needed for hand pain, no more than 3 g a day **S**

## Plan so far

- Hand exercise and joint protection: daily thumb-stabilizing and range-of-motion exercises, padded and thicker tool handles, a lighter mallet, and rest breaks during carving, taught in a course of occupational hand therapy. Guideline: 2019 American College of Rheumatology/Arthritis Foundation Guideline for the Management of Osteoarthritis of the Hand, Hip, and Knee (2019); CMID: Clinical Monitoring Intelligence Database, rheumatoid arthritis and osteoarthritis monograph (2026) **S**
- Hand-based thumb splint for the left first carpometacarpal joint during heavy work and at night. Guideline: 2019 American College of Rheumatology/Arthritis Foundation Guideline for the Management of Osteoarthritis of the Hand, Hip, and Knee (2019); CMID: Clinical Monitoring Intelligence Database, rheumatoid arthritis and osteoarthritis monograph (2026) **S**
- Stop over-the-counter ibuprofen; use topical diclofenac gel first and acetaminophen as needed up to 3 g a day; avoid regular oral NSAIDs at his age because of kidney, blood pressure, bleeding, and gout risks; recheck creatinine in four weeks. Guideline: 2019 American College of Rheumatology/Arthritis Foundation Guideline for the Management of Osteoarthritis of the Hand, Hip, and Knee (2019); American Geriatrics Society 2023 Updated AGS Beers Criteria for Potentially Inappropriate Medication Use in Older Adults (2023); CMID: Clinical Monitoring Intelligence Database, rheumatoid arthritis and osteoarthritis monograph (2026) **S**
- CMID osteoarthritis monitoring: pain rating, a validated function measure, grip strength, and joint examination at each visit; ALT when acetaminophen is used regularly; creatinine, blood count, and blood pressure if oral NSAIDs are ever used; no routine repeat radiographs; periodic mood and sleep screening. Guideline: 2019 American College of Rheumatology/Arthritis Foundation Guideline for the Management of Osteoarthritis of the Hand, Hip, and Knee (2019); CMID: Clinical Monitoring Intelligence Database, rheumatoid arthritis and osteoarthritis monograph (2026) **S**
- Continue allopurinol 200 mg daily with serum urate every six months at target; drink at least 2 L of water a day to prevent stones. Guideline: 2020 American College of Rheumatology Guideline for the Management of Gout (2020); Medical Management of Kidney Stones: AUA Guideline (2014, amended 2019) **S**
- Falls prevention: platform ladder with a rail, never climbing alone, good studio lighting, and a yearly fall-risk check. Guideline: CMID: Clinical Monitoring Intelligence Database, rheumatoid arthritis and osteoarthritis monograph (2026) **S**
