# Otolaryngology (otology/neurotology) Referral

> **SYNTHETIC RECORD, NOT A REAL MEDICAL RECORD**

- Patient: Martin Luther (real historical name used in a fictional teaching record)
- Synthetic MRN: HR-RE004-SYN-TD
- Date: 1527-07-28
- Fictional facility: St. Posthumous Health Center
- Fictional author: Ottilie Brandt-Mensah, MD
- Calendar frame: true historical dates (modern content is anachronistic)

> True-date frame: synthetic events are moved into the patient's historical lifetime. Codes, instruments, and treatments remain modern and are anachronistic.

- To: Friedrich Okafor-Lindqvist, MD, Otolaryngology (otology/neurotology)
- Urgency: Within two weeks

## Referral question

Recurrent attacks of spinning vertigo for about three months, lasting hours, with roaring tinnitus, fullness and muffled hearing in the left ear, in a 43-year-old man; the tinnitus persists between attacks. Please confirm the cause, arrange audiometry and any imaging, and advise on preventing attacks and protecting his hearing. **S**

## Questions for the consultant

1. Does he meet the criteria for Ménière disease, and in which ear?
2. Could this be vestibular migraine, given his headaches, or another cause such as a vestibular schwannoma or a stroke?
3. Is MRI needed, and are vestibular function tests or electrocochleography useful?
4. What maintenance treatment do you recommend: salt and caffeine limits, a diuretic, betahistine?
5. How should he treat an attack, and what should be done if attacks continue?
6. What can be done for his hearing, tinnitus and balance between attacks?

## Pertinent history

Three attacks in about three months. One forced him to stop speaking in public; the worst, twelve days ago, began with roaring in the left ear that seemed to fill the left side of his head, then spinning, nausea, pallor and collapse without loss of consciousness, settling after a night's sleep except for the tinnitus, which has continued. Headaches on and off for years, and noises in the ears in his twenties. No hearing loss on the right. A urinary stone passed last year. Depression screen positive (PHQ-9 15, item 9 scored 0), being assessed in primary care. Examination today: ear canals and tympanic membranes normal, Weber to the right, no spontaneous nystagmus, normal head impulse test, Dix-Hallpike negative on both sides, normal cranial nerves, coordination and gait. Blood pressure 128/82. Blood count, electrolytes, kidney function, calcium, uric acid and TSH normal. Meclizine 25 mg allowed for severe attacks only. No other medicines; no known allergies. **S**

- Martin Luther was born on 10 November 1483 (Julian calendar) in Eisleben, into a relatively prosperous mining family; his father, Hans, gave him a good education and intended him for law. **D**
- He entered the University of Erfurt in 1501 and became a Master of Arts in 1505; later in 1505, after a vow to St Anna made in a thunderstorm, he entered the Augustinian monastery at Erfurt against his father's wishes, and he was ordained in 1507. **D**
- As a monk, although he made full use of confession, he felt that he was 'a sinner before God with an extremely disturbed conscience', and this anxiety and fear meant that he underwent what he termed Anfechtungen, spiritual trials or temptations, in particular about predestination. **D**
- He became professor of the Bible at Wittenberg in 1512 and held the post until his death. He published the Ninety-Five Theses on 31 October 1517, refused to recant at the Diet of Worms in 1521, was declared an outlaw, was sheltered at the Wartburg, and returned to Wittenberg on 6 March 1522. **D**
- In 1525 he married Katharina von Bora, a former nun; they had six children, two daughters of whom died young. **D**
- In May 1521, at the Wartburg, he wrote to Philipp Melanchthon that the Lord had afflicted him with painful constipation, and that he had not slept all night. **D**
- In the autumn of 1510, in Bologna, he reported severe headache and whizzing in the ear; from 1523, according to his physician Matthias Ratzeberger, he had regular headaches with fainting spells and vertigo. **D**
- From 1526 on he had sporadic attacks of urinary stones, which reminded him of death because of the excruciating pain; the first stone, in 1526, was preceded by headache, heaviness in the head, vertigo and nausea and was passed through the urethra. **D**
- On 22 April 1527 (Julian) a severe attack of dizziness forced him to break off a sermon. **D**
- On the evening of 6 July 1527 (Julian), when he was 43, he had an attack that began with a roaring tinnitus in his left ear, which increased and seemed to fill the left half of his head, followed by nausea, pallor, coldness and a state of collapse without loss of consciousness; he prayed and believed he would not survive the night. After a night's rest all the symptoms had subsided except the tinnitus, which persisted. His friends Justus Jonas and Johannes Bugenhagen wrote accounts of it. **D**
- In the first half of 1527 he was deeply disturbed by disputes with other reformers over the Lord's Supper and suffered severe depression. **D**
- Feldmann concluded from Luther's letters and his friends' reports that the attacks with tinnitus and vertigo that began in 1527 were a typical case of Ménière disease of the left ear, more than 330 years before Ménière's description; earlier writers had read them as a psychiatric disorder or as chronic inflammation of the middle ear, and a later Japanese review reads them as chronic suppurative otitis media. **R**
- Evers, applying modern criteria to the letters, found that some of his vertigo attacks met the criteria for Ménière disease, that others occurred with headaches meeting the criteria for vestibular migraine, and that his headaches partly met the criteria for migraine; he concluded that vestibular migraine with migraine and Ménière disease is possible but not final. **R**

7 later historical claims are omitted because they describe events after the index age. See the teaching note.

Baseline: Hemoglobin: 15.1 g/dL; White cell count: 6.8 10*3/uL; Platelets: 238 10*3/uL; Sodium: 140 mmol/L; Potassium: 4.2 mmol/L; Bicarbonate: 26 mmol/L; Urea nitrogen: 15 mg/dL; Creatinine: 1.02 mg/dL; Glucose: 94 mg/dL; Calcium: 9.7 mg/dL; Uric acid: 6.9 mg/dL; TSH: 1.8 mIU/L; Urine red cells: 1 /[HPF]; Urine pH: 5.5 [pH]; eGFR: 94 mL/min/1.73 m²; PHQ-9: 15; GAD-7: 9. All results are synthetic.

BP 128/82 mmHg; pulse 76 bpm; respirations 14/min; temperature 36.7 °C; oxygen saturation 98% on room air; weight 86 kg; BMI 28.1 kg/m². All vital signs are synthetic.

## Current medications

- Meclizine 25 mg tablet, one by mouth up to every 8 hours during a severe vertigo attack only, for no more than 3 days at a time **S**

## Plan so far

- Diagnostic work-up at intake: ear and neurological examination, positional testing, blood count, kidney function and electrolytes, calcium, uric acid, TSH and urinalysis; a symptom diary of each attack (start, duration, hearing, tinnitus, ear fullness, headache, light sensitivity); formal audiometry at the otology visit. Guideline: Clinical Practice Guideline: Ménière's Disease (2020); Diagnostic criteria for Menière's disease (2015); Vestibular migraine: diagnostic criteria (update) (2022) **S**
- Meclizine only for severe attacks, for no more than three days at a time; sit or lie down at the first warning; no driving, ladders or swimming alone while attacks are active. Guideline: Clinical Practice Guideline: Ménière's Disease (2020) **S**
- Depression: PHQ-9 at every visit, a structured diagnostic interview at the next visit, and a safety plan with the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline and the clinic number. Guideline: Clinical Practice Guideline for the Treatment of Depression Across Three Age Cohorts (2019); CMID: Clinical Monitoring Intelligence Database, depression, bipolar, and mood disorders monograph (2026); VA/DoD Clinical Practice Guideline for Assessment and Management of Patients at Risk for Suicide (2024) **S**
- Stone history: drink enough water to pass at least 2.5 liters of urine a day; serum calcium and uric acid at intake; stone analysis and metabolic testing if another stone occurs. Guideline: Medical Management of Kidney Stones: AUA Guideline (2014) **S**
